Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

http://images.buddytv.com/btv_2_800033859_1_434_593_0_/xander-berkeley-in--.jpg

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So disappointing that they wrote "Gail" Bertram wrong at the beginning of last week's show..It's laughable! This is a huge show and nobody notices it?? How ridiculous!
Honestly, us fans care more about it all than the people who make it..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

BRUNO HELLER INFO LEAKED :--

This is how the end of RJ era will go down , MAJOR SPOILERS!!!!

----

Patrick jane goes into a series of Plans and Creativity to make red john reveal himself , His last plan the plan of tricking red john into coming to kill a "Witness" that patrick has created To a bunch of people he knew Were moles.. He goes to the location where he set up red john and red john is already there , with a gun , he takes off his mask and it shows the sherrif.. jane is very surprised and is shocked , the man who killed his family Is right infront of him , the sherrif says:- Oh well there patrick you sure  proved to be a smart one.. but you couldn't outsmart me as i am going to kill you!
patrick asks him why he did what he did and he just says .. because fuck the police.. With a gangster Face , then a pigeon flys at mcallister and he gets scared , he drops his gun and then patrick takes out his gun and shoots him and wounds him , then lisbon shows up but before medical assessment can reach red john he kills him , jane is then sent to prison to live for 25 years ,  ,, The season finale of the mentalist comes in and heres the big twist.. Lisbon gets together with haffner , jane is in prison , and then Lisbon says:- " Are you coming to bed honey" , he says oh yeah just a minute , he goes out to the window and smiles creepily and says using Red johns voice..:-- Goodbye patrick , now im going to go fuck the women you failed to touch for 6 years.. and then it ends.. oh and rigsbys son turns out to be a serial killer and will be a spin off for the show

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Many claim that McAllister is too old, but...

He is said to be 45 years old in his S01E02 appearance, which makes him approximately 50 years old now in 2013. The young Red John was at the Elliston Farm in 1988, which would make the Sheriff 25 years old at the time. Nick Nordella is playing a "young man" in episodes 7 & 8, which many think is the young Red John. Nordella is currently 25 years old....

I can see a scenario where Stiles shepherded a young McAllister to focus and rehab a troubled man. He ended up turning a dull knife into a scalpel. This is why he helps Patrick somewhat, he feels partly responsible for his family's murders.

Of course Stiles could be RJ himself. I've just enjoyed the whole storyline. My first choice was Bertram over the past years, but I'm gonna stick with the two best and most entertaining actors' characters:

Stiles and/or McAllister

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Rj has a phobia and it became clear that the Sheriff to the dove and geese ( ornitofobhia )
When Luther Wainwright died at the end of the scene you see a police car on a sting operation , FBI CBI
When the blind Rj was always said that it smelled like pine ( For there to be in the area to smell like everyday )
Rj is said that it could be handed the sheriff shoots right footed , but when Jane except having 2 hands grabs loose with his left


The sheriff is moving quietly without anyone knowing as RJ
In every scene you see the Sheriff always occupies the place also is narcissistic and think it's the only one who asked him to Jane that tutee
It is the only one who has played with Jane
The only one that comes in a chapter without having anything to do with Rj 1x02 (before Chapter 6 obviously)

" as people change appearance when he dies , right " he tells Jane not know , then says " you're a visionary or a madman has psychic powers " being told that Lisbon was then counsel for the Sheriff believed I was a seer ?
The sheriff is 50 and the drawing of the farm is 25 years ago (said by Cho )
Sheriff RJ also silva
Lorelei when he gave the said Sheriff Thomas macallister list why? because it is narcissistic rjspecial agent said no boss bertram smith or perhaps more importantres charges then why say sheriff ?
When Bosco Silhouette killed suspected security camera --- > by silhouette is Haffner, Stiles , and Smith Berstram ruled Mcallister , age and height Kirkland
Bertram 's office 6x02 when Jane entered the first thing he saw was the Sheriff ... When Rj commits his act first thing you see is the red Smile its caricature
9 THE poem by W. Blake saysTiger , tiger, burning bright that ,the forests of the nightWhat immortal hand or eye whatdare frame thy fearful symmetry ?
and the 6x02 cap Sheriff says he wanted to make the goal of his forest, and before he had told her to tell Sheriff Tom not as named Lorelei ( perhaps I speak in code to get tyger tyger and false rj )
Cap 1x02 : in questioning the sheriff there being shown as this will move the suspect 's face and it hesitates a little ( may be hypnotism )


sorry my english 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Look at this frame from the extended promo of next episode

http://i.imgur.com/YUpV0wt.jpg

It appear as if McAllister suddenly caught PJ's attention while staying calm.

the promo is here : http://www.spoilertv.com/2013/10/the-mentalist-episode-606-fire-and_4337.html

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

http://imageupper.com/i/?S0200010090011M13831493402132607

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on