Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Guys, ...... Red John is dead....for sure.

In love and in war there are no rules. I guess you know we were courted for 5 long years. We were lied, we were told lots of untruths by a mastermind. But that's what the love is. Finally we fell in love with this show. We let it in our hearts, we let it in our homes. And just like every person deeply in love, we believed in everything.

And so, in this delicate situation, being vulnerable, we were fucked. First figuratively, just like people are fucking when in love. Second, we were fucked up. Literally.

Bruno Heller cheated on us. Things like this happen every day. There is a possibility, that some day BH would like to get back in our hearts, using our weakness - Red John. But he will never rule again our minds, cause, you know, there will always be that bitter sense of....being cheated.

In some other post, I will try to explain why Bruno Heller was not intentionally bad in that 6x8. The man just failed. Things like this happen. And I am just very sorry about that. The final fight between Jane and RJ had not to be epic. It should have been legendary. But it was lame.

I am sorry, guys, Red John is dead!









Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I just want to know how McAllister started the Blake Association.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

He ho ha he he ha ho ho ho ha he ha ha ha, (What does the joker say ?)

McAllister is RJ.
Storyline are not always what the producers expected it to be.
Money, boss, ... It would not be the first TV show to be fucked up cuz of various things.
BH didnt even know who could be RJ at the beginning. Its a the best way to badly end a TV show.
I think they are trying to make it new. If ppl likes the new Janes the tv show will continue, If not, maybe we will have a new RJ or the show will end like crap.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

To Stoopkid

How can Rigsby be RJ when in the season 4 finale he is hand cuffed and under arrest with the rest of the team at the time RJ is talking to Jane in the back of the car ?

In the season 1 finale, Rigsby is in the car with Cho when RJ is at the farm with Jane and the Sheriff.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The Red John storyline was brought up in the pilot.  Every season finale of the first 5 seasons had Red John as part of the plot for that episode.  Until 6X09, every single episode had red or a shade of red in the title.  All the seasons have gone over 20 episodes.  Why did the Red John saga end 8 episodes into a season?  I made a list of possible reasons why they did this.  Some are based on the idea RJ is dead, and some are based on the idea that RJ is alive (and most likely not mcallister).

Red John is dead arguments
1) CBS wanted the RJ storyline to be over with and they wanted to try to get new fans with this new beginning thing.
2) Killing RJ was not the only climax they were planning on.  The other being Jane and Lisbon getting romantically involved.
3) They wanted to "explore" Jane's life after RJ.

Red John is alive arguments
4) The season 6 finale will be RJ related
5) RJ manipulated Patrick into becoming a serial killer as well
6) They wanted the fans to forget about RJ so they could bring him back
7) Jane is in a coma or we are watching someone's dream.

Tell me which ones you agree or disagree with.  Obviously, it could be combinations of these reasons or other ones I didn't think of.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think that McAllister can't be Red John. There was a lot of birds in lastest season and there was 2 things that dont match:

McAllister said he hates "those things" - he meant bird that attacked him on church tower.

In episode when Lisbon drove to house where Partridge was, there was a room with group of birds inside.

I think that Red John is bird lover (whistling is way to comunicate with those animals), so McAllister was fake, which had to mislead PJ, but I bet it didnt work.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Yes @hbjbjhjbjhb or whatever your name is, Brody is dead, he was hanged in public. And you know what, I don't care that people here found out this way! On this website I got so much abuse in the past, people calling me horrible names that I would never use! I never ever use bad, humiliating words for other people, here it happens all the time.That's bullying so it's not me who did something wrong. 

And don't bother to comment, I won't read them, I didn't read them before either. If you guys talked to others with respect, people here would respect you more! I don't give a damn that I told you about Brody! Stoopkid & Co deserve it for ruining this website!

Good bye!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on