Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

So now, after being really depressed for a few hours, I tried to watch the episode again and I have to say that I actually like the idea of RJ showed like a wuss, I Iike the 911 call, showing how hopeless and pathetic he is, and then PJ made him regret killing his family and seeing the fear in his eyes when he is seconds away from the death. I wanted so many things to be explained, but if you think about this from PJ's POV, he finally has the killer of his family, he doesn't care about any of that, any of the tricks RJ pulled, he just wants it all to end

I think there will not be another episode, cuz the idea of the writers was how PJ kills RJ and the story moves on, therefore the feel of rushing and very little things explained, but that makes all the clues given in the past episodes pointless. I still have my hopes up  tho

And to finish, imo from PJ's pov this actually makes sense but from another gven what the whole show is about it really doesn't, big disappointment

Oh, and also I think the disappointment comes from the really big hopes for an epic ending to the Red John chapter, and the fact that he is a normal person like everyone else after all and not a God that doesn't make any mistakes...showed how he dies miserable, lonely man, begging for mercy, fearing death like every human being does. I do feel tho, that the episode is really badly written, I guess I kinda like some of the concepts, but the overall writing and directing sucks big time imo

Let me know what you guys think! Hope to see ya round :P
Here the song from the promo btw, I really liked it
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kZY1cLQbrY

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Originally I supported Ray Haffner as Red John, then you all had me convinced that partridge was going to come back to life.  When I saw the leak I too couldnt believe it was McAllister.  He is barely in the show.  Watch the main episode that he was in again and it will make more sense I promise you, season 1 episode 2.  See hownhe watches PJ so closely, see how he changes when nobody is watching, see how the cops respond to his aid, see  how he tries to kill van pelt.  Its him alright.  He lays low after that, this also shows why he takes an interest in pj after the start of episode 2. He acts through his network after that, but notice that his close friend dubar was also a sheriff.

watch older episodes again knowing who red john was and it begins to make more sense. Just think of the clues in a practical sense rather than a hunt for bigfoot or aliens where we are drawing crazy conclusions all over the place.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Here I am again.

I try to imagined Chuck Norris saw the Red John episode, and this was his reaction :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46CxvJqaGxg

BeMyGuest
or somebody else fan, please, if you can transform or subtitled this video somehow connected about RJ
episode, that would be great also, like Hitler video :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Thare's no such a thing like fake episode :/ Heller screw up the hole thing

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It's over....

McAllister Is Red John.

The leaked episode has PJ killing RJ.... it's a shame, because this is a deja vu.  And me guess? PJ will not go to Jail once again!!   It's funny how this series makes killing so easy... and you never end up in jail.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Plot twist : Bruno Heller trolled us by making us believe he is trolling us.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

+++ Leaked Episode is Real +++

Someone on spoilertv posted that the real episode is now live on iTunes in French (I'm not French, so maybe someone here can confirm this?) - and it is indeed the same as the leaked episode.

Should we replace WhoIsRedJohn by WhoWasRedJohn now, as we all know that his sad excuse of a time filler called "episode 8" doesn't answer anything?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on