Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

What a worthless ending.  The final meeting between RJ and Jane totally lacked atomosphere. I mean, where is that evil Moriarty who outsmarts and charm everyone?

Are you seriously telling me this bald sheriff managed to make all those people follow him like some God. Lorelei, Kristina Frye and Rosalind Harker?

RJ was just afraid the whole episode, running like a scared child, begging for his life. Where is the genius? Where's the man that's supposed to resemble Jane and wanting to be friends with him?

He couldn't even predict that Patrick would have something up his sleeve (literally) and happily go in front of him. What a stupid man.

This whole season has been so mentally retarded and un-genius it's embarrasing. This for a show that's called "The Mentalist" and should all be about mindgames.

Fire all writers, including Bruno Heller but only after they go out in public and apologize!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

IT COULDNT BE MCALISTER!!!! THEY NEVER SHOOK HANDS IN 1x02 :O i saw the leaked episode i know its him, I'm just saying... BIG PLOT HOLE

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The actor who plays Mcallister is a really great actor Its just bad writing and a very dry ending. The problem is really with the red john profile. It changed from an artistic serial killer with a great twisted mind to a leader of a secret organisation. He killed more with plain guns than his real killings. Even if he is a simple guy who likes to shoot everything with a face he is not good at being simple either. I think this secret organisation thing planted into show to make things easier for red john and explaining easier why he can get away with anything but it took his intelligence too also the writers creativity they just choose the easy way. say tiger tiger and every things all right. And for fucks sake all the clues? are we deluded did we just made them up!? just explain it we can leave fbi-cbi bullshit to next episode. I can understand why Patrick didn't care how red john did what he did but we do. agghhh never mind. I WILL NEVER WATCH A WEEK TO WEEK SERIES AGAIN. Only good old serialised quality shows. I think writers got used to tie things in a really lazy way.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It really wouldn't be viable or logistically possible for CBS to create two separate episodes.

Its the sheriff, sorry my friends

:( God Dammit CBS

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

ALSO Mcallister NEVER shakes patrick's hand in their first encounter....

Source: 1x02

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Where is the Red John music that sends shivers down my spine. ha? HA????

That music that scares us to death when we hear it everytime Red John sound or the smiley face?????


?????????????????????????????????????? 

I'm confused..there is no possible way they can redo it

It's really really disappointed ending to the Great Red John!! 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on