Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Go on to iTunes and buy season 1 episode 2 "red hair and silver tape" which is the first time jane and Mcallister meet. after rewatching this episode, i can somewhat be okay with Mcallister being RJ i wish they did it better, but at least its plausible. However i still do not understand why RJ let patrick beat him at rock paper scissors... you would think an extremely intelligent narcissist wouldn't let that happen....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely




WORS SERIAL KILLER REVEAL IN THE HISTORY OF TV DRAMA









GOOD GOD, I CANT BELIVE I SPENT ALL THAT TIME TRYING TO COME UP WITH WHO RED JOHN IS!!!!!!!!!.

At Patrick's house McAllistar said he's not RED JOHN , WE HAVE BEEN FED FOR SIX YEARS THAT RED JOHN IS AN ARTIST MENTALIST MORE LIKE AN EVIL SIDE OF JANE

OH MY GOD IM SOOOOOOO UPSET RIGHT NOW 


HE IS WEAK... THAT PERFORMANCE WAS WEAK AS HELL SPECIALLY FROM XANDER!!


OH MY GOD ALL THE THEORIES AND THINKING!




WORS SERIAL KILLER REVEAL IN THE HISTORY OF TV DRAMA

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There was nothing in that episode saying McAllister was definitely RJ, i hope Jane gets a call in a future episode which says "Hello Patrick" in that creepy ass voice. That was a shit end to a good story and i hope Heller is lying saying it is definitely over.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Let me clear my throat (or my hand, since I'm typing) for some good old fashioned gloating:

If you ever wrote a theory about Jane, or Mashburn, or Grace, or Minelli, or Cho, or anyone not on the list of seven suspects, then you are an idiot. We simply laughed at your theories and waited for this day, when we would clown your retarded ass for those insipid and foolish piece of shit you called "theories." Go fuck yourselves. Fucktards.

To Partridge fans:
Tell me, how does it feel to be wrong? Didn't we warn you? Didn't we say that this ghoul was dead? Didn't the actor who played him say that his character was dead? Didn't you see Lisbon watch him die, as he faintly said, "Tyger, Tyger," in the hopes that Lisbon was a member and would come to his bitch-ass rescue? I love the irony that the suspect with the most theories and votes was the first to be bitch-slapped and killed by RJ. I revel in your misery and your tears. Go fuck yourselves. Motherfucking fucktards!

To Kirkland fans:
How the fuck can Bob Kirkland be Red John? Seriously? I can understand suspecting him before he was shot and killed, but after? Why would he be killing the suspects on the list of Jane's fake suspects if he had the real one? Even after he was shot six times, some of you retards still thought that he was Red John; come on!

To McAllister fans:
A big round of applause for your ingenuity or luck. You were right. Revel in your victory.

To Reed Smith Fans:
If you wrote a theory about Ree........; LMAO. I forgot, there are little to nonexistent Reede fans. This is whoisredjohn.com, not whowantstoeatredjohn.com. No one with an iota of sense suspected his fat-ass. Word on the streets is that Jane's daughter has more theories than this bloated idiot.

To Stiles, Bertram, Haffner Fans:
I have nothing to say about you!

To CBS, Bruno Heller, the writers, directors, producers:
Go fuck yourselves. Thank you for the worst reveal episode, till date, since the beginning of television.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i just rewatched it and it wasnt that bad but wtf, jane told mcallister that he faked his death and brett partridge (the forensics guy) made it so it seemed as mcallister was dead.... WTF isn't partridge dead? Script error or is partridge magically alive...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Heller, Heller, burning bright,
In the forests of the night;
What immortal hand or eye,
Could frame thy stupid episode?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Tsssssssssssss Mcallister is red john ....

Thank you for this amazing revelation ............





WHY THE FUCK DID YOU CHOOSE RANDOMLY RED JOHN ?? YOU RUINED THE SHOW

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on