Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Bertram is not RJ, in fact RJ is a woman

Why would PJ send all law inforcement in a manhunt of the man he wants to catch and kill? he doesn´t need a national hunt for Bertram if he wanted him he will deduce his whereabouts, find him and kill him, PJ actions towards Bertram,  do not fit at all, at list after he drops he tea cup, what fits to PJ MO is to give a false lead to have everyone looking and wanting to catch Bertram who is in fact a killer and a crooked cop and needs to be found and put away ,  meanwhile he can get  RJ and kill him with out interruptions or anyone stopping him. Of course Bertram is a Killer , who other type of people would help a serial killer other than a sociopath.

Cheers Folks!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Think that only Gale Bertram is the only one remaining in the list of suspects? think again. Here is the new list of suspects:

- Brett Partridge: He was in the same room with Lisbon and RJ before he "died". We didn't see Cho check the face of the corpse, we didn't see his death on-screen, and the cut on the corpse left shoulder is interesting. He might be still alive, and he is my prime suspect as RJ.

- Michael Kirkland: The twin brother of Robert, technically on the list since he looks exactly like Robert, not confirmed if dead or alive, so he is on the list.

- Bret Stile: The body found was burned and charred, and linked to Stiles via DNA only. The writers gave this the time and effort to be explained in the episode. Also Lisbon said that she thought even a nuclear bomb wouldn't kill him. So he is still on the list.

- Gale Bertram: I don't think that he is RJ, but he is still alive and he was on the original list.

Now at the end of the episode, we see some scenes from a church, which I think are symbolic. I am thinking "resurrection", which could refer to either Bret stiles, Kirkland, or Brett Partridge who are thought dead. Stiles promises that he will return during his ritual. Also "III", which might mean the three remaining suspects other than Bertram, or the three dots in the Blake Association's tattoo. 

Also, there are events that weren't shown. Who fired the shot at Jane's house, and how did the explosion happen?


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

From this episode we learned:

Gale Bertram is NOT Red John.
Brett Partridge is NOT Red John
Reede Smith is NOT Red John

And we also knew:

Bob Kirkland is NOT Red John.

That leaves us the Sheriff, Ray haffner and Bret Stiles.

Is not the Sheriff. 

Is between Ray and Bret. But I think that none of them is Red John and we are going to be surprised!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I feel that if some serious magic isn't pulled of in the next episode, and i mean serious magic, then the mentalist is the worst tv series i've seen till now. No explanations of so many things, no surprise element, suspects dying left and right randomly in an explosion, clues contradicting each other, holes in the plot everywhere. At least some sort of consolation will be when RJ is revealed to not be Bertram, but still.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I have screengrabbed Gale Bertrams USB list.
Have fun with decoding it:

http://www.ezekiel-rage.com/images/images/menta-list.jpg

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

HERE IT GOES MA NIGHHAZ!!! ROLL UP YOUR SLEEVES BIETCHEEEZZ!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ep. 7 SPOILERS ahead, read at your own risk.






Judging by the comments here I'm not the only one who was disappointed.

First off, I was expecting some explanation about what happened in PJ's house in between the gunshot and the explosion. And about who fired anyway, at whom, etc.
It also honestly annoys me (almost since the beginning of the season,but in this episode especially) that no one seems to give a flying f*ck about those who die. They get killed off and we move on. Personally I didn't want Stiles dead (even though he was dying anyway). I didn't want Bob dead for that matter.
It all just looks like the creators don't care about Patrick being smart any more, they just care about finishing this ASAP.

And Bertram = RJ? If they'd made it more believable. I can't seem to buy it no matter how hard I try. 'Kay, he definitely doesn't have a problem with killing random innocent people. But I don't believe RJ would kill Patrick in his sleep without ever talking to him one on one as RJ, the one who killed his family.

What I liked in this episode was Reede Smith though. I was surprised when he turned himself in, and I liked when they questioned him. Seems like he got into the Blake Club kinda by accident?
I also enjoyed watching Patrick interrogate the other Tyger cop, reading his expressions.

So I think it's safe to say Bertram is the leader of the conspiracy, since he cited Blake before, and Smith said that someone in the organization is a major fan. If he is also proven to be RJ, im gonna be one sad Mentalist fan.

All in all it just seems very obvious that they're rushing this hunt. Maybe too much.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on