Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

I've seen the promo for "The Red Tattoo" and i fear it will eliminate Ray Haffner as a suspect, he'll still be alive (he's in the episode after, so he's deffo still alive), but he won't be RJ. He'll probably be a member of the Tyger club, but not RJ, which is annoying because he's been my guy since the Red Barn.

My new suspect is based on an unusual theory. We're assuming it was RJ who "rescued" Michael Kirkland from alcoholism and despair, what if it was Bret Stiles, and Michael Kirkland is actually his apprentice, Red John. 

Would be cruel irony that Bob Kirkland was killed trying to gain info on his twin, who he believes to be dead. And if Michael is RJ, i can see RJ being a touch pissed that the Tyger club killed his brother, and he'll probably seek to eliminate all members of the club.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This show is better when there's 1 normal case, with nothing to do with redjohn, and odd times, the end 1 clue that actually means something.

The way this tiger tiger thing is going, it sounds like I might never rewatch a single redjohn episode, its left that sour a taste in me. I enjoy Jane, and mysteries: the way it was from season 1-4. Not conspiracies 5-6.

I dont know if this page existed 4 years ago, but making the theories then was  exciting, writing  or in our head. Now my own theories of whats going to happen worry me.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The 5 seasons were great...this 6 season is...horrible...it is like : I didnt know what to do with the plot season! What now? Pj will hunt one RJ or the entire organization?? Maybe he should blow up the FBI, CBI and Homeland security and then MAYBE he would kill RJ and his organization. End of story ! ;) Heller said we would be disappointed when we fin out who RJ is right? Well i must say he is doing a great job considering that!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I post a theory a week ago and i say that Kirkland will die in this episode,i accuse Haffner  to be RJ but this episode i saw that RJ it's an organization and RJ it's probably the leader maybe the members of the organization don;t know who is Red John the real identity.I think that Haffner,Mc.Allister,Bertram and Smith are the members and one of them is RJ,i don';t think that Bret Stilles is a membre or he is RJ i think he will help Jane to catch RJ and because next episode it;s about Vizualize i think that will be very interesting.

I think Brett Patridge know about the organization(Kirkland told him maybe) that he say "tiger tiger" to Teresea to warn her,and that was kill by RJ because he know about the organization not because he was on Jane list.

And about the theory that Kirkland twin brother is RJ it's very interesting because we know that Lorelai Martins had a twin sister.

It's RJ it's not the leader of this organization if he is a seriall killer create be the Bertram,Haffner,Smith and Mc.Alister to take the blame for the kills if you know what i mean, it will be very dissapointed.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm so confused right now. The plot has never been like this. I look forward to episode 9.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There is a big Jisbon moment confirmed in episode 6! Who's excited???

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Wow guys. I was really disappointed with the last episode, because I don't like the idea of Tyger Tyger team, it is so simple and disturbing.

But this? The 6373 team? Waaay worse. He or they keep promoting the theory 6373.

http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/6373

First it was on the main page, now it is in comments. I am really sick of seeing the advertisement of theory 6373. Can you tell me exactly after how many times will you stop? How many plausible votes do you need to stop? I will simply program a bot and give you that to shut your mouths.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on