Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

'Pygeon, Pygeon', the new TM secret organization created to change bad episodes and scenes. A secret group of TM viewers
eliminates/destroys film and replaces it with more plausible,
entertaining scripts and re-shot episodes. The writers, instead of being
heaped with scorn, are given "medals", like Reede Smith. Everyone's
happy.



Pygeon, Pygeon...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm @xxxxxxxx on twitter and I read your tweet about the mentalist episode.

Be aware that you may likely have seen the alternate version of the
Red John episode. A contact of mine in the industry had told me of two
versions of the episode. They are not fully different episodes, they
only have different men revealed as Red John and the final showdown as
well. About 8 minutes of alternate footage, he said. This is not
unusual, networks have done this before with episodes that have a great
buzz.

I was not told who either men where in each version and would very much like it if you could send me the link you have.




She could be full of crap, or she could be legit. I just wanted to share it with you all.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

CONCLUSION 


1-
WHEN THE BOSS OF A CERTAIN POLICE DEPARTMENT IS CORRUPT ,DO NOT WORRY ABOUT IT ,JUST FBI TO SHUT DOWN THE WHOLE UNIT?

2-WE DONT NEED TO USE WEAPONS ANYMORE ,WEVE GOT PIGEONS 

3-WHEN YOU SEE AN INJURED MAN RUNNING ,DO NOT TRY TO HELP HIM ,JUST SCREAM

4-IF YOU WORK IN A PETROL STATION AND YOU WITNESS A MURDER ,DO NOT SCREAM OR YELL ,JUST WATCH IT CAREFULLY CZ THEY WILL LET YOU LIVE

5-DEAD PEOPLE COULD SPOOF UP AND CHANGE SOMEONES DNA ,AND HE COULD STILL BE DEAD
(PARTRIDGE)

6-CERTAIN BOMBS COULD GET PEOPLE TO FAINT EXECPT FOR ONE ,THEN ,THAT SAME PERSON COULD DO WHATEVER HE WANTS WITH THE SCENE THEN BOMBS CERTAIN PEOPLE BLA BLA BLA NO BODY KNOWS HOW THIS WORKS THOUGH

7-SPANISH GANGS COULD DROP YOU TO WHEREVER YOU WANT TO GO.

8-WHEN PARK YOUR CAR WHEREVER ,KIDS TAKE IT FOR A TEST DRIVE

9-WHEN YOU ARREST A TEAM ,YOU HANDCUFF EVERY ONE BUT THEIR BOSS

10-EVERY SEAT IN THE CHURCH HAS A GUN PLACES UNDER 

11-WHEN SOME ONE GETS SHOT ,HE SAYS ,HEYY THEN HE DROPS 

12-RANDOM WOMEN GO TO CHURCHES WITH KNIVES 

13-THE WAY THE FBI PARK THEIR CARS IS AWESOME

14-WHEN YOU SEE SOME MAN WALKING TO YOUR HOUSE JUST SCREAM THEN WAIT FOR THE NEXT ONE TO COME AND JUST GIVE HIM YOUR PHONE

15-THIS WAS THE SILLIEST SHOW EVER

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i believe heller wants to appease the people on this forum as they are the ones about whom he would think:  these buggers are not gonna be satisfied even if I make Obama the rj thing.....they would say "ah, this is all the clever guy cud muster"..so its not bad to make sure these ppl are happy..

well, you dont think that the hardest to please junta would be the ones
on this forum and why did heller come out and say 6 months back :
"people will be disappointed in the revel"..coz he is nervous that yes
its so and only like 2% would fall under that category..but he is
worried about that 2% coz they are the cleverest and its gonna be im
possible to make them digest the real rj after 6 yrs of myth and they
would be the ones trolling the internet after the revel pouring their
frustation which would affect the hseeple followers into thinking its a
lame show..this is consumer psychology biz dear..and u are judgemental
inthinking i dont kow tht i am speaking..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

no i dont think an episode let alone a few scenes cost millions.....money wudne be a consideration at all for that as its a 6 year old hit show. now, the opinion makers and influencers about the rj revel are all people who are now active on this forum. now heller's whole legacy is gonna be judged by these people as they are the ones who would troll the internet forum in days to come and either make him a hero or crucify him (irony with the church scene).....so he can sure spend some time and energy to appease us..:)..makes me feel good....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok. So major studios make 100 million dollar movies and every once in awhile they will make a 5 minute alternate ending that doesn't blow their budget and that 5 minutes is a small part of what they want to do and is in the back of a DVDYet a TV show that has fans but has no one figuring out who their main plot killer is besides a few people on a website leads writers to spend time making a COMPLETE fake episode to trick fans and spend a ton of CBS money? And they accidentally leak it to trick a small amount of fans even though there is no way to know who the killer is. AND the leak is getting no press but on a fan site.....can we just admit that the final show is what you saw and Partridge and no one else is coming back...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I do not give two fucks if you think I'm "delusional" but I have a strong feeling this is all a spoof. The question is WHY wouldn't Bruno spends millions (wait how can one episode be millions) The Mentalist has always been a great show with amazing plot twists and shit.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on