Who is Red John?

Theories of Alexander (5)

What if! ...
Thomas McAllister AKA red john, did not killed Janes family...
What if it was someone else...

What I want to discuss is the possibility, that Red John sent someone else to do his job for him.
 I mean the idea it self is a debatable topic.

(write a comment about what you think) 
(
and also GREEN for possible red unpossible)

Side Thougts:
 
- The entire so-called climax with bringing the section was not bad but not that I think anyone had expected, we all had our favorites (mine was speculation about Michael Kirkland, Bob kirlands twin, I could really see it as an exciting reveal)





Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This is what I am thinking at the moment.

I was the last accuser of Patrick Jane that actually got a positive result  LOL I am proud.

So where are we now.

I am starting to think that a member of the team will definitely end up being part of the tiger tiger group. The tattoo is quite well spread in law enforcement. I think RJ will be part of this tiger group. However Nobody in the group will know or suspect that he is RJ. This person will also be known to Bret Styles.

RJ is definitely not on the 7 suspects list. I am completely sure of that.

The biggest clue I have read as to the identity of RJ is from an Interview from the actress that plays Lisbon. Here is the quote.... which is the biggest clue yet when asked what she thought of the choice of RJ

"I was surprised, and had I been Red John, I would have been equally surprised,"

So..... if RJ turned out to be Lisbon..... 98% of the people reading this would be surprised.

She's not, by the quote, but RJ is very much someone that we don't suspect, hence we are going to be surprised.

So who would surprise you?

It is highly possible its a member of the team. Unlikely but possible all the same. I would say Cho would be my choice. What can be done with him when Rigsby and Van Pelt leave? RJ may not necessarily be killed, he may just escape. Cho killing VP and Rigsby would be quite shocking. Also he is an interesting character that we don't know that much about. Other then he does everything, by the book.

I am still hoping for the PJ = RJ swerve, be great to see where they went with it, if it isn't cancelled by then.

Afterall they could have kept Timothy Carter as RJ and continued the series focusing on other aspects. That would have been a believable conclusion. They had to do a bit of digging to get out of that one. Must be for a good reason :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Article in Irish Times UK from Lisbon.

Sounds like RJ could be a main character or at least someone very unexpected

http://www.independent.ie/woman/celeb-news/tunney-shocked-at-red-john-reveal-29707739.html

The unveiling of the serial killer - the nemesis of mentalist Patrick Jane (played by Simon Baker) - is set to be revealed in the upcoming sixth season of the US show.


.

"I was surprised, and had I been Red John, I would have been equally surprised," she said.Robin, who plays Senior Special Agent Teresa Lisbon on the show, admitted she was kept in the dark until the episode.


"I did not know at the beginning of the season. We're a bit ahead of you as far as filming goes, and yes, the audience will find out who Red John is," she continued, adding: "It's been exhausting. That's all I'll say."The 41-year-old laughed off rumours that her character is the cold-blooded murderer."Some days when you're bored and you want to feel badly about the show, you read things about yourself on the internet. It never ends well, like a Shakespearean lesson," she said.



"I was reading on one of the sites that 'Maybe Lisbon is Red John', and someone else said: 'Don't be ridiculous. There's no way that Lisbon is Red John'. And I'm like: 'Wait a minute!' I took umbrage at the idea that it was a sexist thing - a woman can be a serial killer."With the big reveal happening, Robin admitted she has signed up for one more series, saying: "We don't know; there's been a really interesting evolution. Simon and I are both signed up for seven years so we have one more year on our contracts."The sixth series of The Mentalist starts on Channel 5 on October 29

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #7570 • By Alexander
Show this theory

So..... They put trackers on the 7 suspects phones. They allude to that at the start of the episode.

They suspect red john is killing the private investigator.......

and they don't say look at the trackers and see who is there........

this is just getting sloppy

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I have always been an advocate of PJ as RJ or at least the possibilty of it being him. They constantly do teases that it is. Here are a couple from the last episode. 1) PJ is scared of heights. Evidence - when he gets taken out onto the church roof, before hand he says. I would love to go out there but i dont have wings charlie. He then proceeds to crawl and pretty much say ooooooh. Then something like Charlie saying we will find a way down and PJ saying that is what i am afraid of. He is also terrified when the sheriff helps him and crawls back in.2( he then says and I quote "sending out mixed messages is one of my many failings" 3) mcallister then says at your disposal any time 4) Why did PJ not enter the wedding,. STRANGE.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on