Who is Red John?

Theories of PropJoe (1)

the awkward moment when the fake red john (timothy carter) was absolutely more interesting and far better portrayed than the real red john.
he fulfilled all my expectations. he had attitude, showed no remorse or fear and was arrogant. so creepy and beautifully played by bradley whitford.

the whole mall scene was just brilliant. i really loved how patrick sat calmly and continued to drink his tea after he killed him. an episode worthy of ending.
i can't believe that the same guy who made strawberries and cream could make such a horrible episode like this one is. he failed when it was most needed,

should have swapped those two episodes.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
Follow us on