Who is Red John?

Theories of d666q_3 (25)

I totally understand the frustration of those who had hoped for answers or at least somthing that might indicate they still intend to give any.

While I am not a big fan of the episode as such I get why they wrote it like that.

The RJ fanbase was getting weakener at the latest during season 5, because people where tired of waiting for an answer to the riddle. The majority of them wouldn't have accepted for this arc to be extended into season 7. In an interview from 2009 Heller stated that the conclusion of RJ would be a series ender rather then a season ender.

http://tvseriesfinale.com/tv-show/the-mentalist-last-episode-plans/

Baker and Tunny both had contracts for 7 seasons so they had a vested interest to get another season. While the RJ crowd deminished,  JIsbon shippers were a consistent and loyal fanbase. It made sense to use a good portion of the season to further build that base with the hope to get renewed for season 7 and it worked! Blue Bird was the well earned reward for this part of the fanbase. To be honest it was the Jisbon shippers that kept the show on the air.  

With the season finale playing out like it did most will have given up hope for further answers. I am not one of them and here is how I would connect the season finale to the RJ story line.

Janes big romantic gesture, the crying, the confessions of love were a con with the single purpose to keep Lisbon around. 
The reason to keep her around would either be that he is investigating Lisbon as a possible RJ or her being an important piece of leverage against RJ.

The fake letter was his attempt to keep her around by only giving her a romantic gesture and avoid commiting to anything more concrete. Once this attempt failed he had to go all in.

Notice his very composed and manipulative facial expression in that last scene before Lisbon enters the room. Also once she brings up the subject Jane returns to being  as evasive as possible with out risking to make her change her mind. In the very last seconds he avoids repeating what he said on the plane and instead leans in to kiss her.

So in essence there are two major fanbases the RJ camp and the Jisbon camp. He can't give the RJ camp without destroying any possibility for season 7 so he gives the Jisbon people what they crave. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Since there aren't many tangible things to guess where they might take the Season finale I thought it might be fun to share a new inside joke I found smuggled into their set design:

The original FBI logo looks like this:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/70/US-FBI-ShadedSeal.svg/300px-US-FBI-ShadedSe....

The initials of their Motto "Fidelity, Bravery, Integrity" again add up to FBI.

In the show they use a slightly different logo:

http://i57.tinypic.com/nxnrqu.jpg 

The initial of their Motto "Valor, Heroism, Service" add up to VHS, which is the video standard that was most common before the DVD-Player came along.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just wanted to share a neat documentary I found on youtube. It aired just prior to the season 1 finale. In between a lot of typical idealizing there are a few very interesting tid bits, especially in part 1:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Ho05_Npzcg&list=PLy0CY2IDLfZaustsJVeJToNXQEsyeEZNT

For example around 4:30:
It's Heller describing the show followed by Baker. Bakers facial expression when he talks about deception is just priceless. You can really see how much he appreciates the irony of being deceitful while still giving an honest answer.
They cut back to him again at 5:55, after that there is the the part about mentalism that continues in part 2 and maybe the most interesting thing about that documentary. 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-lt3_fCWOk&list=PLy0CY2IDLfZaustsJVeJToNXQEsyeEZNT

At 0:30 of the second part the show a clip from 116 saying Jane reads Van Pelt non verbals. In fact at that point of time in the episode he is supposed to be blind, if that is in fact the case a very bad example to chose otherwise a great one. Also like that woman mentalists comentary.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Not a theory just a curious connection.

What do you think? Is this the reference for the title forest green?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oh5Hk5XC_YM

Holly Miranda (From her album "Magician's Private Library")





"Forest Green Oh Forest Green"







Catching clocks and broken glass

Past the bridges and smoke stacks

You look like what I might lack

Open up your head there's something missing



Who's got nothing to run from,

Do you?



Near eyelashes and a stream

Forest green oh forest green

Up past cities made of steam

Open up your head we found a secret



Near eyelashes and a stream

Forest green oh forest green

Up past cities made of steam

Open up your head we found a secret



Who's got nothing to run from,

Do you?

I do

I do




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Unmasking the assailant and the kidnapper of Grace van Pelt.

The assailant was Donny Culpepper, the man kidnapping Grace van Pelt was Dr. Linus Wagner.
Why?

Because
on the press release both actors were listed as guest-starring(as Culpepper and Wagner), but
didn't appear at all throughout the entire episode, except in the
picture of the suspect list.

You might argue that the picture appearance on the list
alone was sufficient for a credit as guest starring. If that was the
case why were the actors playing Haibach, Volker, Cooper, Ed Hunt and
Buddy Hennings not credited for their picture appearance?

The kidnapper was a rather small and thin guy while the assailant appeared much more muscular. Culpepper has a pretty solid stature, so out of those two only Wagner fits the frame of the kidnapper, therefore Culpepper must be the assailant...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Most interesting thing in this episode for me was Graces ring tone. I
didn't notice it the last episode, the melody is different but the
instrument playing is the same as in the jingle the cooperative uses.

I
think the cooperative will be the replacement for Red John. They helped
Dan Becker in his fight against "big oil" and with their anti
establishment bias they might very well have help Haibach in his fight
against government agents who wronged him. The whole bugging and hacking angle makes much more sense with them as perpetrators as well.

One of the passengers
on the bus vouching for Haibach is Mark Hochmann. Mark Hochman
was also listed as the one bringing forth the sexual harassment charge
against Bryce Kendrick.

[IMG]http://i57.tinypic.com/14jvj8n.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i57.tinypic.com/2qmj6fn.jpg[/IMG]


Mark Hochman is also one of the unknown  CBI Agents targeted in the bugging.

[IMG]http://i59.tinypic.com/wv5zkm.jpg[/IMG]

Other unknown characters on that list are Chris Kieffer, Claudia Chavez, Salvador Palacio, Deborah Chernier and Mike Riner.

Now there is a curious connection to be observed if we look at the list of Janes former clients cross referenced with Lynch Halstedt in back in 116:

[IMG]http://i59.tinypic.com/2isz40j.jpg[/IMG]

We can see that Chris Kieffer, Deborah Chernier, Mike Riner and Claudia Chavez are listed on the Lynch Halstedt records and there is a Herbert Palacio in there as well.

Haibach claims there are three people vouching for him, but actually there are 4 signatures. The first one is Mark Hochman and last one is Allan Davis.

If we look at Janes client list we can see that both Hochman and Davis are listed as former clients of his.  Also worth noting there are clients called "Amy Haffner" and "Karla Kieffer" as well.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I accuse Patrick Jane of tampering with Sophie Millers psychological profile of Jay Roth. I believe it is actually the psychological profile of Patrick Jane we are listening to.

Remember Jane arrived at Sophie Millers home way before the police did and discovered the digital recorder. The missing patient file of Jay Roth could have been stolen, but it is also possible that it never existed because there was no Jay Roth.

The reason for my suspicion can be found in the scene where Sophie Millers diagnostic is being read out loud.

Here is a youtube clip of that scene:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QyCexbs0I0M

At arround 1:02 after Kirkland the camera focuses on Janes face. The voice over is saying "though I cannot point to identifiable clinical behaviors that indicate this." Look at his left eye (on the right side from our perspective) there are 3 nervous twitches.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on