I have read a theory (theory #1315 by BeMyGuest1201)so I wanted to investigate... and I found something very interesting!
In
that theory, the user reports that if you pay attention and listen to
5x13 episode, you can hear that the steps of Red John (in the redhead
girl's flashback) were limping.
Well, I remember very well a guy who was lame!
go
to 2x08 episode; this is one of my theory: Do you remember CARTER PEAK?
Red John's supposed fourth victim? What if HE was (and he IS) Red John?
Carter
Peak had an amputated leg and he used a prosthesis (we can see him on
Patrick's reenactment of the murder). Carter Peak is played by Casey
Pieretti and he has actually an amputated leg, but he is a stunt-man and
he is a great skater, so you shouldn't think that he is unable to do what Red John does.
His height is
5' 10½" (1.79 m, compatible with Roy Tagliaferro's height)
and he was born in 1966, so he is 47 years old.
Patrick
assumes that Red John want to hide Peak's DNA evidence, but what if he
wants to hide only the body? Maybe it isn't Carter Peak's body and Red
John makes Patrick to find the X-ray plates to make him believe that it
was.
Now pay close attention on 2x08 episode, min. 30:30;
Patrick
asks Rebecca a question and we all focus on her answer. BUT WAIT! When
Patrick mentions the DNA samples Rebecca has a strange reaction: She
mumbles a "mmm?" as to say "what are you talking about? DNA samples???".
So
I think that Red John's mistake is not what they make us to suppose.
And maybe the body they found was another person. Towlen Morning's death
is also weird: his body was frozen, so maybe it was taken from a morgue
cold chamber and maybe it isn't Morning's real body.
But there
is an element against this theory: Carter Peak lost his leg during the
first gulf war and it began in 1991; so in 1988 Carter Peak still had
his leg. So his steps were not limping, isn't it?
That's all!
I don't believe much in Carter Peak/Red John theory even if I thought it; but I believe that Peak's case is much more interesting than it seems. And so is also Morning's case.
What do you think about this?
