Here I am again!
Guys, I have a theory for you and it could be a big one:
In the episode 6x02 we can listen dr. Miller's description of Red John, that she met as Jay Roth.
There are a lot of details and I think that the whistle stuff is the one which most people has noticed.
But I think it's a distractor clue (three suspects whistled on the episode).
I think that the real big clue is the phobia stuff.
Mr. Roth mentioned the acrophobia, but dr. Miller was not convinced; she said he has some kind of phobia, but she doesn't know which one.
Well, that's the point of my theory:
the pigeons!
Red John is ornithophobic, so he is scared of pigeons!
At the beginning of the episode 6x02 Patrick said: "Maybe something spooked him and he couldn't go through his usual routine."
The pigeons! The pigeons spooked him!
There would be some reason why they appear in episode 6x01 and also in episode 6x02; and in this second case, Patrick stares on them like he was thinking about this possibility.
Now, why I choose once again Haffner for this theory:
because he fits the description, yep, but there is another reason.
He said to Lisbon: "I like you, Teresa. I really do! And one of these days, you and me... we'll have the time."
It sounds like he wants to remedy to his first chance with her on that abandoned house. Plus, Red John caressed her cheek while drowing his mark on her face.
So, if I'm right: find the one who is scared of pigeons (or birds, or feathers) and you'll find Red John! And if I'm right, that one will be Haffner.
