Who is Red John?

Theories of Kathrin (3)

Is it just me? I am completely obsessed with who Red John is! Every evening I am surfing this site and looking out for news on the mentalist in the internet.

I need to find a new Hobby once Red John is revealed. Can't wait for the big reveal.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In no way is Brett Partridge Red John. I really cannot see how he can make others follow him. I know that RJ can play the role of anyone he wants to but Plotnick just does not have the attributes of an RJ in real life - how can he all of for sudden be irresistible if the real life actor is not. He might be a good actor but I think he was part of tyger, tyger. When Patrick met him in season 6 episode 1 he seemed very nervous. I think RJ killed him because Brett couldn't keep it together anymore. He posed a threat to the wider organisation and that's the reason he was killed.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The person who is Red John would have been alarmed by Patrick's address. They would have known that this is where Patrick's family was killed. This person must have suspected that Patrick wanted revenge and probably planned an exit strategy - e.g. Planned the bomb or an explosion to distract and escape.

I don't like anyone on the list but if I had to pick I would pick Haffner. He is the only one who is similar to Patrick: about the same age, same height, relatively attractive (not close to Patrick's Devine level of attractiveness but more attractive than the rest) and charismatic... The perfect Red John would have been Mashburn!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on