Who is Red John

The Hightower conundrum is solved by Tiger Tiger trying to kill her, not Red John. At no point do I recall that we know that O'Laughlin was working for Red John. He may have been part of Tiger Tiger instead. My biggest question now becomes how did Timothy Carter know to be in the food court. He would have had to have Bertram's office bugged?

O'Laughlin belonging to Tiger Tiger and killing Todd Johnson makes more sense than Red John having him killed. The police officers killed by Todd Johnson were being weeded out by Tiger Tiger. Remember Todd Johnson said that "this is bigger than you could image," similar to what Reede Smith said to Kirkland.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theory #4297 • By Mano

Show this theory

Though we cant pin Patrick completely, Somehow the authour needs to Corner Patrick Jane as Red John as no one else could be a better choice at this moment... Need to cook a lot more possibilities to make PJ as RJ..Bruno needs to fill the holes which he left that rules out Patrick.
There is no one showed as heroic other than Jane which inturn cannot fit perfect if someone else is introduced or Identified as Red John :-))

Other possibilities,
Someone from CBI should be RJ.
Lisbon should be an Insider..
Betram should be an Insider or himself Red John.. :-)

Conflicts,
Narrowing the list is fine, Giving the suspects name is also fine but how the hell would RJ know the count(7) has been shortlisted ???? Okay we can accept it too, Let RJ have capabilities of reading PJ mind.
But i guess Patrick Narrowed down the list after Loreli Martin's death.. But The Video which gives the detail of Jane's findings was played by Loreli Martin and how the hell could that happen.. This Video proves that there is no sense or logic in the Script itself.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of Mano (2)