Who is Red John?

Theories of Randumbness (1)

Theory #647 • By Randumbness
Show this theory

Such a shame Timothy Carter wasn't Red John. He fit the bill in every single way. Maybe Heller wanted to extend this RJ saga because the viewers loved the story line, so he decided to make someone else RJ or convince us Jane is RJ. So many twists in this show its hard to believe anything. Now we have a suspect list and Virgil stands out as RJ, also Partridge.

Almost everyone is a viable suspect in some way of Red Johns madness.

Timothy Carter is not Roy Tagliaferro but does that mean he wasn't RJ?
Or was he Roy and Rosalind lied?

Who knows what to think?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on