Who is Red John

I honestly don't trust the list.And other thing RJ should be one man army, evil genius and manipulator with devoted minions. All of his friends show great admiration for him, Rebecca talk about his mission of enlightement and that it has nothing to do with Tiger Tiger gang.
If it was that silly group Jane would discover that in an month, not in 5 years.
Let face it, only if they were all master manipulators like Jane they could get away for so long.If RJ is a group there is lot of weak links and they would break easily.
So as I said one person modern Professor Moriarty with qualities of PJ,Walter Mashburn and Brett Stiles.

I believe now Todd Johnson was killing members of Tiger club and if he knew RJ, they were on a same mission.They say to Jane that there is a bigger picture and explanation for everything.
But if the list is true then Haffner is the only one that fits.

MCalister looks even emphatic for Jane or he is RJ.

I really hope Heller will finish this story in the right way,RJ as a one mastermind vs PJ. battle of minds not man vs group.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Some things here are makes you think twice.
Red John is a powerful person well connected and with loyal minions who are not naive miserable persons and still they all talk about him with admiration like some kind of a deity.

So how some clown can become so powerful more powerful then some billionaires or high state officials.Brett Stiles is a clue but not necessary the RJ himself, maybe father or he do something bad to RJ family so he protect him now and paying his debt.
Anyway I believe that RJ had a bigger reason to kill Jane's family maybe revenge or who knows what.

RJ is womanizer and powerful man and only people like that could control and impress beautiful and strong person like Lorelei.So i would put my money on Mashburn. .
I see RJ as modern professor Moriarty on his mission.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of Ruber_Iohannes (2)