I think that none of those on the list are actual suspects but rather a game. If you remember Jane put a toothpick in the door and when he returned he found it on the floor. When he picked it up he had somewhat of a half smile on his face, like someone was suppose to break in and see his board. Knowing someone would come he created a fake list that red john fell for, I mean we haven't seen what happened after he broke that dvd. The way the show has gone in the past this seems like a plausible theory to me. However I have heard the creator or someone said that red john IS in fact on the list, so it isn't likely unless he lied which maybe, but I think this would have been a good clever way to catch him maybe
anyway
I can eliminate one of the suspects in the list based on previous information, the visualize lead. Red john was someone in his late teens or 20s on that farm 25 years ago making him 45ish-55 years of age. Bret Stiles is too old, the actor that plays him is 70.
Kirkland is an obvious choice the way he is so creepy, but I feel like he is more of an accomplice.
Of those on the list the only ones that seems plausible to me are Haffner and Partridge
Both seem obvious though, we are somewhat lead to believe that Haffner was on that farm which could make him the killer obviously. Partridge's voice sound so much like the times we have heard red john's voice which again makes him obvious then.
If the list is real I'd go with partridge, but honestly he is kind of a random character, and if he is RJ that is a moderately lame ending. Any of them being red john......I like my idea better
