Middle aged, in good health, well spoken, good posture, self possessed, excellent whistler, pleasent self presentation, deceptive and dark, real phobia.
So aren't Bertram, Stiles and the sheriff too old to fit the description "middle aged"? Also Stiles doesn't seem to fit the description "in good health" and "good posture".
The Sheriffs reaction to Jane leaving the room in 6x02 was "what the hell was that all about" - I wouldn't call that "well spoken".
Important note is that Sophie millers says that Red John's phobia is real wether it's acrophobia or some other phobia.
In 6x05 Haffner freaks out when he sees a spider and says he hates spiders (arachnophobia).
What are your thoughts?
