Who is Red John?

Theories of marcus-78 (1)

I won't argue about the identity of RJ in this post. I just like to know, why do some of you believe that the list is fake.

I think the list is genuine and Patrick Jane made it to the best of his knowledge (Although he could be wrong). Why?

- He already planted a fake list. Kirkland got it. So, his list was protected. Another faked list.
- I like the idea of Lorelei and Patrick faking the video, but I can't see the point of it. RJ would not be thrown of the hook by it. He would know it's fake. And as far as we know nobody outside the team did see or hear about it. So, either you suspect someone on the team or the video is genuine
- Patrick did include people on the list that do not fit all the descriptions of RJ (Betram is bold, Smith is too tall and too big boned). He was carefull not to eleminate anybody on account of potential false information.

So, where do you think I'm going wrong. What have I missed?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on