Who is Red John?

Theories of redladybug (1)

Theory #7292 • By redladybug
Show this theory

Stay with me, folks.  I firmly believe that someone else that we've already met is his twin.  I believe this for one simple reason- from the first episode and all the way through- drinking tea in America with a proper tea plate and cup as a highly unusual trait (it's not England people).  We know that Patrick really never knew his mother (possible split up at birth kind of thing) and the fact that both of them are ardent tea drinkers is a HUGE clue that has been laid out from the beginning.  Whether it ends up being a listee or not, it will be someone that has a deep connection to Patrick, even a jealousy, which requires him/her to HAVE to outsmart Patrick therefore keeping him alive. That is why Bruno says we'll be let down when he unmasks RJ- the audience has already guessed that it could be Jane's twin.  Maybe that person is on the list and maybe not, but follow the tea where it leads...follow the tea.....and Jane's genetically blue eyes.  Whoever they are, they have blue eyes. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on