Who is Red John?

Theories of theorider (2)

The Mentalist has been nominated for Favorite TV Crime Drama at the 2014 Peoples Choice Awards!

Let's all show the people who make this show how much we appreciate their work and VOTE, VOTE, VOTE until voting closes on December 5th.

VOTE HERE: http://www.peopleschoice.com/pca/vote/votenow.jsp

You can also vote on twitter by including the following in any tweet: The Mentalist #tvcrimedrama #PeoplesChoice

You can also download the app and vote easily from there.

Vote as many times as you can! There's no limit.

Thanks and let's WIN.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hey guys

This is more like an observation than a real theory.
I my opinion i have no doubt that the video with Lorelei is made by her and PJ.

And i think i have multible proof for my theory:

1.: PJ tells Lisbon that the list contains seven names before he is given the disk. I does not tell her that he has a "list", he tells her that he has "a list of seven". The odds are really really low that RJ has the exact same list af PJ!

2.: If Lorelei really are dead, then the video is made before Kirkland breaks in at PJ's place. That means RJ must have known that PJ would end up with the 7, witch either makes have a genious or PJ (witch i highly doubt). This means that either has PJ and Lorelei made the video before she died, or she is in fact not dead!

My best guess is that this is done by the mastermind of PJ to protect Lisbon or who else might get hurt. I also think that this rules out Lisbon as an RJ accomplice. Because if she was, she would have to go to RJ right after she saw the video, she would also know that the tape is fake.

I think PJ knows who RJ is, but he has to be sure before making his move. I also do not believe that Lorelei is dead!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on