Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

In the pilot episode why did they focus on the paramedics forearm tattoo? In Red John's Friends it's obvious the girl wrote the message (blood on hands, facing the wall) and she was mexican so maybe her english wasn't very good. Could she have been trying to describe her killer as "He is marked"? 

I do like Walter Mashburn for Red John though.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Robert "Bob" Kirkland 

He ask for information on the red john's when they show jane's introduction into  the cbi.
he shakes jane's hand, and when janes asked "do i know you?", he simply replies "no, but i know you."

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In response to the comment below:
I did not see lorelai, however Gale bertram reffered to Patrick as "The boy wonder"
How could he possibly know Jane's old stage name? Unless it's common knowledge or written in his case file but I don't see why it would be relevant...
Food for thought..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I know its Gale Bertram. Lorelei said the thingy with the hand shaking, right?
so she had to be there watching "Red John" and Jane shaking hands, RIGHT?
So, there is a little video where Bertram and Jane are shaking hands
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66iBKnc4wlA
Look closely at Minute 1:29 top of the right corner who is standing there.
What do you think? I'm pretty sure its Lorelei. Let me know what you think about that. :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Bob Kirkland from Homeland security.  Watch season 5 episode 7.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

 I'm glad i found this site and the fans on here that i can chat with about the show. It's one of my favorite shows. House(rip) Breaking Bad, Person of Interest, Justified. The Walking Dead, Dexter, Homeland, The Mentalist, Elementary, Monk(rip)Psych, and Seinfeld reruns are classic and never get old.  

Also, If you enjoy The Mentalist, Then you'd enjoy White Collar.

If you guys don't mind, i would like to submit my opinion. I have no theory about who red john is. But i have a few comments based on simple deduction i have deduced during the series.
   
 Bret Stiles, J.J. Laroche, Gale Bertram, and Walter Mashburn (no particular order) are all decently plausible suspects.  I'll throw in Susan Darcy just so my list won't seem sexist. 


 Grace Van Pelt, Oscar Ardiles, Wayne Rigsby, Summer Edgecomb, Lorelei Martins, and Harker Rosalind are all too young to be red john

 i consider Minelli, Lisbon, Hightower, Cho, and Frye as friends of Jane, So i doubt it's any of them.

Stiener, Wainright, O'Laughlin, and Bosco are all dead, So it's not them. they are dead with witnesses to their respective deaths

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There are many people who kill others without so much as an expression
on their face.They don't feel excited when they're doing it, they are
perfectly calm and if you check their pulse, it's normal during the act
of murdering another being.Those kinds of people don't really kill for
hedonistic reasons, they either kill for money(as in being a hitman or
inheriting a fortune), for prestige(something that has to do with how
proud they are, feeling of control and power) or for a mission(that is
to say they believe they achieve something by doing the deed, like
ridding the world of evil men or saving it).As humans, they are all
unstable persons, but as killers, they are not unstable because they
don't have an urge to kill like a sadistic killer who does it because he
gets off of it.Because they can actually stop, after they have enough
money, status or accomplishing their mission and they don't kill
spontaneously.But a pleasure oriented killer never stops because he
revels in it.And there are more types of hedonistic ones, like the
fantasy fulfilling ones, revengeful ones(targets a specific type of
people like only men, women, prostitutes, rich people) and so on and so
forth.
If you ask me, Brett clearly seems the type that is pleasure
oriented(that is if he is a serial killer) while Red John seems like the
mission oriented serial killer(the higher path, nobler existence, he
has a mission of love-Rebecca's words) and also the one that is looking
for prestige(killing Jane family to show Jane he's wrong and give him
power over him, killing everyone that insults him like that interviewer
who called him "beast" and James Panzer who brag that he surpassed Red
John's status as a serial killer).
But here's the thing, Red John's
profile obviously changed since the first season.At the end of the first
season, he seemed to be the pleasure oriented type, actually he clearly
was meant to be like that.Killing only women(revengeful type), cutting
them with a knife(indicating that it is something personal like he felt
he was betrayed by women or he was really traumatised by one when he was
young, maybe she raped him or killed his family), entering their rooms
at night, waking them to see the fear in their eyes, cutting them and
waiting for them to bleed out(the fantasy fulfilling type).As we can
observe, he was clearly meant to be a hedonistic(pleasure oriented)
serial killer in the first season, the only person he kills that doesn't
match his profile is Jared Renfrew, which was basically forced to do it
since Jared pose a threat to him having info about him.Then in the
second season, Red John changes a lot, he gets an upgrade, he has
disciples willing to do anything for him(even die), he is an educated
person(reciting Blake's poem) and he's resourceful.The more we find out
about him, the more complex he becomes, his profile is changing and he
doesn't even match his serial killer persona because serial killers
don't have followers, at least not usually, he matches more the con man
with his own cult like L. Ron Hubbard which is why it was obvious for me
that sooner or later it will be revealed he has some ties with
Visualize, since Visualize is cult just like scientology, actually
Visualize seems to be a parody of scientology.
This is why Brett
Partridge can't be Red John, he was a perfect candidate in the first
season(he was my first suspect and the obvious culprit in the first
season, no one else could be Red John in the first season) when Red
John's profile was that of a hedonistic serial killer, but then Heller
changed Red John a lot for the plot sake.That's because the first season
is just like the pilot episode, if it's good, your series gets renewed
for a second season, if not it gets canceled.That's why they make two
season finale, one that opens the road for a second season(if the series
is renewed) and one that ends the series at the end of the first
season(in case they don't get the approval for continuing the
series).Since Heller couldn't know if his series will have a second
season, he made a few Red John centric episodes and in the finale, he
had Patrick getting close to Red John.That formula was used in every
season from 1 to 4, because Heller was in the same situation, not
knowing if the series gets a new season, he had to be ready to end it at
that season.But now it's different because Heller has confirmation that
his series will have 7 seasons(or at least 6 seasons) so he knows he
doesn't have to end it this season in case it gets canceled.That's why
we get more info about Red John in almost every episode, little by
little we get there.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on