Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

First off, I should say, I’ve only watched the “McAllister
is Red John” episode. The Sunday episode, I haven’t seen.




This post contains information about Sunday’s
premiere of the “Red John” v1 episode, and what you can expect to happen. (At
end)


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Common Mentalist Misconceptions- This goes from
very simple to more complex explanations.




The alternate episode is the only episode.


Wrong. This is the
biggest episode in the history of the show. Creating an alternate ending blocks
every chance of leaks from media, and provides a hilarious twist. As a
Mentalist fan, you should be able to spot a trick when you see one. Shame on
you, if you still think it’s real.




Gale Bertram, Thomas McAllister and Reede Smith
are bad guys.


Wrong. Gale Bertram
and Robert Kirkland have been working together before Bertram was even director
of CBI. Kirkland meets Minelli in season 2, and it is only after this meeting
that Minelli retires. Minelli and Kirkland decided it would be appropriate if
Bertram, a spy in Tyger Tyger, could go up the ranks in law-enforcement. This
would allow him to be entrusted with more information on the conspiracy.

In the meeting of 3
suspects (Reede, Bertram, McAllister), they are discussing how they will
organise the arrests of members of Tyger Tyger.  



Reede Smith shot Robert Kirkland


Wrong. He shot
Michael. Look at the beer belly! You think Patrick Jane is a real psychic, and that’s
how he knew what Tyger Tyger was when he was interviewing Reede Smith?  Nope. Robert Kirkland, who is still alive told
him. More to come on this…



Gale Bertram calls Red John after Patrick
invites him to the meeting at his house.


Wrong.Gale Bertram
calls Robert Kirkland. At this point, Kirkland briefs Bertram about his large
role in Patrick’s plan.

Red John blew up the House

Wrong. Bob Kirkland
comes in from the other entrance to Patrick’s house and provides surrogates for
the 3 who will “die.” Kirkland has already briefed all 3 spies in Tyger Tyger
(Bertram, Reede and McAllister) meeting about Patrick’s plan. So in the house,
they are just acting. Bob Kirkland and Thomas McAllister kidnap Bret Stiles and
Ray Haffner. Bob Kirkland remains in custody of Bret Stiles, the man who brainwashed
his brother. Kirkland will get his revenge. You see a larger vehicle stopping opposite
Teresa’s speeding car. Robert Kirkland is in there and uses that chance to call
Patrick Jane, and tells him to get ready to blow up the house. Then Reede and
Smith immerse themselves in their roles as fugitives.

The gunshot heard and
the man screaming is Patrick scaring Haffner. Teresa’s phone in Patrick’s car
gives the impression to Red John that Patrick shot Haffner. The explosion is to
suggest Stiles died too.
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


UNIVERSAL MISCONCEPTION:  Gale Bertram is still a really bad guy in
Great Red Dragon!


 



This requires a bit of reading… and
re-watching.




Phase One of Bertram’s Role: Convince Red John
he’s on his team.
Bertram first waits
for Teresa. He gets ready to “kill” Patrick, by ordering Teresa away.  On cue, Jane wakes up and Bertram leaves. Jane
and Bertram have created the illusion that Bertram was going to kill Patrick. Teresa
Lisbon is bugged, and her reaction transmits to Red John.



Phase Two of Bertram’s Role: Leave behind a
Flash Drive for CBI


The flash drive
contains names of people in the Blake Association. But it doesn’t contain every
single name obviously.

 



Phase Three of Bertram’s Role: Keeping up
appearances. (Requires rewatching)


Bertram looks scared
in the pub- he realises what he has to do for the next part of the plan….

Bertram orders ice for
his scotch. Later, Gale Bertram smashes a bottle on the bar guy’s head. The
barman’s head twists in such a manner that blood splatters on the right arm of
Bertram. After that the camera angle is used to deceive viewers. Bertram isn’t
glassing the guy’s neck. He’s breaking something to bathe the barman’s head in
ice.



Robert Kirkland’s
agents sweep in and save the man, sending him medical attention for head
injuries. They replace the Bar Man with another person, much like Jane faked
the death of Rigsby in season 4.

Then Bertram goes to
his residence in Citrus Heights. Kirkland has already planted a SWAT suit in
there.  Then Kirkland calls all SWAT
divisions there to facilitate Bertram’s escape. Patrick uses this opportunity
to call out “He’s one of them.” Teresa is near. The message is transmitted to
Red John that Patrick still thinks Bertram is Red John.



The Next Phase of Patrick’s Plan: Luring out
Red John



Patrick and Kirkland
agree with the flash drive in possession, its best to shut down CBI, and let
agents who definitely aren’t rogue, deal with upcoming Blake Association
arrests. Kirkland asks Alexa Schultz’s FBI to take over.

They’ve got the flash
drive. Kirkland’s got information about Red John from Stiles and Haffner. Kirkland
gets his opportunity to exact revenge on Stiles.

Patrick has his board
set.  He doesn’t need to do much to lure
out … dare I say it…. Partr….nah. I’ll just say Red John is well and truly
played already.



-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Things explained in “Red John.” (original version)

 
-Visualize Barn – why the murders were really
never reported (Stiles + Tagliaferro #1 + RJ’s “connection”)




-Ray Haffner’s crucial involvement with Red
John (How RJ was ahead/ How RJ was in 2 places at once/ How he faked his death
in the season premiere)




- How Partr… Red John’s descriptions from
Rosalynd + Sophie Miller were exactly accurate and why Patrick’s “list” had no
hint of their use


- Roy Tagliaferro both is, and isn’t Red John.
Who “Tagliaferro #1” and “Tagliaferro#2” are, is explained. The “switch”… One
Roy killed Lorelei’s Sister. The Other Roy killed Jane’s family.




-Patrick’s Master Plan; Deception + Misinformation
= Red John actually was “in the bag” as Patrick said in episode 5 to Ray
Haffner




- PJ/RJ. Why RJ never wanted to kill Jane.

 
- Red John and Patrick Jane come face to face;
how long Patrick Jane has known RJ’s identity is the biggest surprise.

 
- Almost all clues are explained implicitly, “He
is ma” and such. Bosco’s dying words are shown for the first time

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The pigeons (with their beady little eyes) have been symbolic for two reasons.

- Heller has us all eating out of his hand.

- And yes, this fake episode reveal has thrown the cat amongst the pigeons.


I am still refusing to believe that episode is what will be broadcast.

(And Patrick getting a lift to the cemetery in the pimp mobile: and still taking about 20 minutes to greet the guy who gave him the lift - this while his nemesis allegedly waits inside? Another one......why does Patrick run about as fast as Mr Bean? Surely you move your ASS when you're chasing RJ? He was strolling........)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Please disregard my last post: I'm a bigger dumbass than Bruno Heller and forgot to put the link to the website in the damn post. 

So HERE IS THE LINK: red-john.info

Here's a great compilation of all of our collective frustration at Heller and the Red John reveal.

Check it out! (By the way, if you scroll far enough, you can find my hilarious post!! (theory 14016 in case you were curious. You'll get a good laugh!!)

Heller should have at least taken us all out to dinner because I'm sure we all would have loved to be wined and dined before we got FUCKED. 

Oh well....enjoy your day....somehow. Go scrape some pigeon shit or whatever you do to cope. I eat copious amounts of ice cream. 

Continue to post theories of how the reveal should have went down because I need to wash my brain from Heller's horrid portrayal of it.

See ya later, friends! (I'm not your friend, pal. I'm not your pal, buddy. I'm not your buddy, guy.)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Everybody can write better sricpt than this piece of shit! Fuck Bruno Heller and fuck all The Mentalist episode writers! We are so disappointed! We have been waited for more than 5 years the big reveal, and it was zero! Nothing! There are still hundreds unanswered questions! We had been fooled by son of a bitch Bruno Heller and his team!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Cho is my picture because he's a total badass. PERIOD. 



Here's a great compilation of all of our collective frustration at Heller and the Red John reveal.

Check it out! (By the way, if you scroll far enough, you can find my hilarious post!! (theory 14016 in case you were curious. You'll get a good laugh!!)

Heller should have at least taken us all out to dinner because I'm sure we all would have loved to be wined and dined before we got FUCKED. 

Oh well....enjoy your day....somehow. Go scrape some pigeon shit or whatever you do to cope. I eat copious amounts of ice cream. 

Continue to post theories of how the reveal should have went down because I need to wash my brain from Heller's horrid portrayal of it.

See ya later, friends! (I'm not your friend, pal. I'm not your pal, buddy. I'm not your buddy, guy.)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hahaaaaaaa...its very funny that most of you feel that Leaked Video is Real..Looks like BH has won this Round

There was a lot of Discussion few day ago on this forum about the promo and Mcallister could be clearly seen in the video...Honestly,At that point i believed that maybe Mcallister could be Red john but after watching leaked Video i can now confirm that that promo shown to us on last week episode was actually the promo was for the Leaked Video and the same applies for promotional photos

So Guys Buckle up for the sunday's episode you would be on a total dark at the beginning of the episode  because you have no idea how the episode is going to be(No info could be drawn from Promotional pics and promo because they are fake and were actually made for the Leaked Video)

My Favourite show "The Mentalist ' is going to be the first show in TV history to have released a fake video,promo,pics and fool millions of fans and show complete different episode on original airing Date :)


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Searching for explanations about the leaked video i have found this video on youtube posted about a year ago by Bruno Heller and Daniel Cerone. How is that even possible?

http://youtu.be/sE3lNMB5PiY


After you watch the video read my comment below. That is how I think they did it! =)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on