Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Sorry to say, yes it is over. This will be the final season. Rating decline on it has gone down too far to bring it back. It goes up against Sunday Night Football and gets destroyed. It is a bad timeslot & always has been. They may do a episode with flashbacks, but doubtful. Heller is very determined to move away fast from it for the reason that ratings on the new twist could savor one more season, but doubtful. We basically are to come up with our own theories on everything. I liked the Red John episode, but it was dragged on a bit too long. 6 seasons. If you look at the ratings from season 1 to 6. It is like a steady decline. At one point they drew almost a 20.0 share during season 1 & now even the Red John episode was barley over 10.0. That is a huge decline.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

We didn't even get ONE flashback of McAllister AS Red John.  Nothing from the past was really explained except for the freaky voice.  Tons of loose ends remain.  How did a small town Sheriff pull off both Tyger Tyger AND being Red John?  Something doesn't add up. 

It's not over. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16314 • By Silly
Show this theory

This website is dying, just like the show!
Ridiculous theories..Why do you even need more theories?? It's all done now! :D

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The book kim fisher was reading was about history and hr lies that the ruling cast plants as history. "Daughters of time". Very interesting ;)
Also, rigsby has been weird all season.
He knew info that seemed like he wouldnt
He helped the fbi
Now he doesnt think about the cbi
Interesting

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well missStiles should go to therapy for being scared about people who gives their opinion about a show.
Now, this is the first time i ever share a theory, but there are some things that i think is important to notice.
In episode 6x01, did u guys notice how lisbon fell? Im not near a brett partridge fan or want him to be red john , i dont have any red john favorite i just want to know who is the real(cant be McCallister he is just so lame), comin back to the scene moment.... looks like she is grabbed from the floor and got knocked out by the fall. So , you may ask... and the blood from partridge? well he is a forensics guy , he saved some of his own blood for that moment and faked the dna from the body , which wouldnt be hard from red john to fake his own death, he even call patrick not caring about the voice because jane wouldnt think that red john will do that stupid thing.
The main characteristic of red john is that he wouldnt let someone do the dirty work for him, he is a showman, an artist , an artist wouldnt let someone else do the work, HE has to do it, so... every kill when the red smile appears, red john has killed. So when patrick was save from the crazy guys in 2x23, he probably wasnt red john, i think that guy was timothy carter , the voice and everything was from him and from the 6x01 we can deduce the real red john is partridge . Is that or believe that Mcsissyallister managed to kill partridge and knock out lisbon surrounded by pigeons. Why would partridge let lisbon alive? So she could tell patrick she witnessed an injured partridge.
I really believe that a genius, like red john is supposed to be, the "moriarty" of jane (like heller said in an interview) wouldnt kill a suspect from the 7 list because why in the world will you make things easier for jane. 7 is much better than 6, at that point jane didnt have any real clue, partridge was even member of the blake association !!!!!! Why would red john kill him?? , makes no sense. What makes sense is that a genius, inmediately wants to get erased from that list.
So the big question here is why would jane , a genius too, wouldnt see all this , the fake death, the fake clues... why? because he wants to move on he wants closure, he cant be objective about red john or smart as he usually is because all that he wants is to see him die.
Maybe thats why he didnt want to go back to california, to avoid finding another clue or even thinking that McAllister wasnt the right guy.

And dont ever believe that cunt of heller, he already told the audience that we would have answers , and we didnt , now he say its over, so he is a lier and one of the two possibilities is the truth, because of that everyone has the right to keep making theories until the end of the series arrive.
Thats all.
P.D sorry for bad english.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hahahaha what!!! I have a problem with women cuz i have a crush on van pelt ? That makes me psycho? Your hatred for me is psyho im just using my noggin. U dont think agent fisher is weird ? I mean shes already two faced ? Sorry am i women bashing for saying that hahah . You dont know anything about me . This a website about a tv program . Calm down. Sometimes women can be killers too. Like all the episodes where jane catches the psycho wife for murder or does that mean heller has a female issue too?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16310 • By MissStiles
Show this theory

I'm sorry but this "Stoopkid" person who posts here every day is a crazy psycho..He has a problem with women and keeps accusing Van Pelt and even the new woman, Agent Fisher.. This person is a psycho and it's embarrassing for this website.
Soon only sick weirdos will visit this page because everyone decent and normal will want to escape this crazyness...Weirdos accusing someone from the past while everyone has already moved on...These crazy people scare me! 

Respect to all the fans who have accepted the bullshit changes and they will decide for themselves if they want to follow the show or not.. I will, because of hottie Simon Baker...Sure, we are not happy, but at least we are not delusional psychos, who keep banging on and on  about the same thing week after week..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on