What McAllister said -- "You got it wrong.  I'm not Red John" -- was true.

Red John hypnotized and used McAllister

I'm just done re-watching the Season 2 finale on DVD. My plan was to watch all the episodes leading to the long awaited conclusion.

Well, the disapointment was great after the seemingly uninspirational reveal by BH, but someone I WANT TO BELIEVE that there will be more, that there could be more to come.

The theories on this page all have more to it than the show delivered in S6E08 - and I read and enjoy your theories alot. Thank you very much!

Now - if you're as unsatisfied as I am: keep believing in BH genius and hope despite all other statements of cast and crew that there will be an epic conclusion to season 6. Including all the answers we dream about.

I dont know If anybody already posted this,
but in s.6 e.7 PJ & Lisbon are talking
after Reede was Interviewed and PJ Said
"Red John would never beg like that, not even
in an act"!!
I find that very contradictory.. In the "RJ reveal"
the sheriff is without a doubt VERY MUCH
BEGGING for his life!! I a very stupid
non-believable Way..

Maybe its BAD story-writing
OR
very GOOD

Maybe it Was a little hint and hope
to those of us who still dont Believe
the real RJ is not yet revealed

Sorry my bad english, I am Danish ;-)

What was RJ connection to Visualize ? We had Stiles knowing about where Kristina Fry was and then the Red Barn episode that underlined a connection between RJ and Visualize and then nothing ? WTF

How did RJ get the list of 7 suspects ? At the moment it looks like they through it would be a good idea in the writers room to creep everyone out, then when it comes to it they realize they can't explain it and just kill of RJ with the words "i'm a real psychic." - That's not acceptable.

What is the "He is Mar," thing mean ? It can't mean he is marked cause the person would just put tattoo, also can't be he is McAllister, why both when you're dying putting "He is," you'd just put the name.


Cheers