The site's popularity is decreasing day by day.
I think it is in the position that the people who still post on this site are 20 maximum.

So, we can conclude that most of Mentalist fans have accepted what we watched and moved on.I suppose all of us will do the same someday.

I don't want to flame anyone anymore.I don't want to blame Stoopkid or whoever posts uncommon theories in this site.I don't wanna blame Bruno Heller nor Mentalist crew.I don't want to make fun of the fact that Sheriff is Red John and the way that he died.I don't want to watch the rest of the series either.

For me, Red John is still alive.And no, I don't care if the show will end without showing any kind of clues to us so we can assume that RJ is still alive.

It's the healthiest of all things to do.Make a theory that pleases you and answers your questions, (just try not to leave plot holes) and stick with it.Nobody will ever blame you.

I still hope for a twist to happen, but I'm not that optimistic for many reasons, it doesn't matter.It's just a shame, because "The Mentalist" was a truly different kind of TV show than any other.And now it's just a common Crime solving series with nothing special or innovating.
So much potential in this Show, with an appropriate ending would be one of the greatest TV shows ever.
That's my last post in this site, I just wanted to thank all of you for the amazing theories that carried me away, gave me hope, tough me some kind of lesson, amazed me.I will still be reading your theories with excitement.And I hope with all of my heart, that someday I will have the appetite to post again.

 

SOME of RJ's characteristics [if forgetting something, please feel free to add to this list]:


Amazingly charismatic 
Women lay down their lives for him///men want to work for him and be his friend [maybe it's his expert whistling]
even though they openly know he's a serial killer and they're probably next

He kidnaps women, chains them in barns and basements 
and likes to taser, bind, torture, cut people up with linoleum knife and "play" with viscera 
draw smiley faces on the wall in blood
but in spare time, he creates and runs a complex mafia police network named after a his favored poem and then requires special tattoos on such mafia people who have to chant favorite poem to each other [I wonder if he got special deals at a specific tattoo shop?]

He's arrogant, narcissistic, and well spoken, a master hypnotist and mind controller 
and yet plays "dumb yokel" because he's "hiding" that he's smarter than everyone else

well read, presumably educated 

sips tea like he grew up knowing how
likes classical piano music, especially Bach

wearer of a fancy guy ring and nice looking watch, as well as fine suits

also wearer of hoodies, cowboy boots, plastic masks and a wedding ring
who will "hunt anything with a face," skin and quarter it

He's "just under six feet tall, with short, straight hair, not muscular but not soft, with strong hands"
and McAllister is 6 ft tall, long and lean, severely balding with what hair he has slightly wavy when it's longer than an inch  -- and often wearing facial hair

"Middle aged"
McAllister is more "grandpa status" [nearer to 60 than to 40]. 

"gentle voice"
McAllister has gravelly texture to masculine voice that he can freakishly turn into a high pitched troll voice

He's an expert in forensics 
AND surveillance 
AND computer hacking  [that's A LOT of training]

He's afraid of birds 
but not of walking on rooftops


He's used and killed untold numbers of people
and yet begs for mercy when he's about to be killed, admitting he's sorry

He has conjugal visits with blind redhead that he hangs out with for a couple of months in San Angelo [near Los Angeles]
EVEN THOUGH he ALSO has a REGULAR job as a small town Sheriff that he has to show up for everyday with regular shifts presumably

He smells of pine, dirt and metal -- even though paperwork, police car, coffee and cigarettes, beer, deer guts and beef jerky, grapes and wine are more likely

AND MY PERSONAL FAVORITE!

He can be anywhere around the state of California at a moment's notice --- from Napa Valley to Sacramento to Los Angeles to Tijuana and back up again all in a day's work!



WOW, what a GUY!  



I'm sorry, I'm not buying that McAllister was ALL of these things.  
Sounds like a lot of different people.

Thomas macalister is red john and bruno heller sucks so bad .

What if EVERY post looked like this?
This is what you want me to write ?
I am entitled to my opinion as are you.
But why rain on our parade ? Just to be mean?
You cant prove me wrong and i cant prove you wrong .
Just leave it at that and LET US POST WHAT WE WANT WITHOUT BEING CALLED NAMES !!!

To Stoopkid

How can Rigsby be RJ when in the season 4 finale he is hand cuffed and under arrest with the rest of the team at the time RJ is talking to Jane in the back of the car ?

In the season 1 finale, Rigsby is in the car with Cho when RJ is at the farm with Jane and the Sheriff.

Guys, ...... Red John is dead....for sure.

In love and in war there are no rules. I guess you know we were courted for 5 long years. We were lied, we were told lots of untruths by a mastermind. But that's what the love is. Finally we fell in love with this show. We let it in our hearts, we let it in our homes. And just like every person deeply in love, we believed in everything.

And so, in this delicate situation, being vulnerable, we were fucked. First figuratively, just like people are fucking when in love. Second, we were fucked up. Literally.

Bruno Heller cheated on us. Things like this happen every day. There is a possibility, that some day BH would like to get back in our hearts, using our weakness - Red John. But he will never rule again our minds, cause, you know, there will always be that bitter sense of....being cheated.

In some other post, I will try to explain why Bruno Heller was not intentionally bad in that 6x8. The man just failed. Things like this happen. And I am just very sorry about that. The final fight between Jane and RJ had not to be epic. It should have been legendary. But it was lame.

I am sorry, guys, Red John is dead!