Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

I have basically abandoned the show and have not kept up with this site.  Even from the early episodes of this season, it was clear what was happening and how bad the show was going to be but many people were too much in denial to see it; and kept the wild tehories going.  So it is kind of satisfying that more and more people have fallen asleep out of boredom while watching the show, and that they are now finally seeing it for what it has become this season: mediocre acting, silly plots, too many characters, disconnected even within a single episode, with boring execution. 

In an effort to keep the con up until the season's end, they had to resort back to the out-of-the-blue suspense tricks, tucked into the last two minutes of the episodes.  Do you really think there is a logical explanation behind this?  Have you not learned your lesson already?  If so, answer a few basic questions:

1. All CBI members are being killed off one by one, over a long period of time.  No one has picked up on this.  Not the local cops and not the FBI.  Really?

2) In any other cop show even slightly based on reality, this will have FBI squarely focused on solving this with all of its resources available.  Here, they are like, "oh, yeah?  well, we got a tip that some illegal workers are sneaking in from Mexico.  Let's go".  Really?

3) In any other show, the remaining targets would be given protective custody and around-the-clock guards, be moved to hidden location until the case is resolved, etc.  Furthermore, they would be removed from the case.  Here, nope: the two targets are actually given the responsibility to solve the case by the FBI.  Why?  Well, because they got another gas station robbery that resulted in murder.

4) Wait, wasn't this show called the Mentalist?  Ooh, bummer, what to do?  Yes, let's have PJ solve the secret of each character's most hidden desires and have him give them their favorite toy from when they were a child.  What?  We used to show how PJ would know these things?  Well, come on.  They have barely spoken to each other.  Can't we just slowly focus the camera away and play elevator music instead?  Yes?  Great, thanks!

What will happen in tonight's episode?  Do you really think there was any thought put into this?  Do you really think RJ will make a comeback?  If so, dream on.  Better yet, wake up already.  The simple reason is the writers/producers realized that they have essentially doubled the number of characters, in two separate locations.  They got themselves into this mess, and now that they realize it, like some of us did a long time ago, they are trimming the cast down. Nothing more.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Mcallister is deathly afraid of birds.  If Red John killed Partridge and tasered Lisbon in a house full of pigeons, then McAllister must be Red John....TRUE OR FALSE?

TWO THINGS THAT DON'T GO TOGETHER:

Red John masterfully traps 2 people in a house with pigeons
and McAllister's bird phobia

Birds didn't have to be in that abandoned house, but we were purposely shown that birds were there.   

The Red John in that house wasn't afraid of birds.



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #17534 • By Waldner
Show this theory

I watched this video, and realised, when the sheriff says "The game is over and I won", his voice is like GVP-s, especially in the end. Just to mention.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ci-aR7jD9Yc



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So I (very rudely) started posting this another another man's (or woman's) theory so I'll repost it here.

I'm starting to think that the whole "old gang" is in on the kidnapping - which would explain why the gang went out for a drink (so that VanPelt could be left alone in the Red motel) and why Lisbon demured (so that she could help set up the caper).  

It is a very Mentalist-y twist - a la "Crimson Hat" where Jane fake murdered Lisbon and Rigsby.

Haibach is a decoy villain because he is easily riled.  That is why Lisbon chooses him when Jane asks about their hunches.  He is used to draw out the real killer.  

If the real killer has eyes within the FBI, it would be one explanation for why everyone was acting so weird around each other.

Or, it is possible that Rigsby and VanPelt weren't even privy to the plan until Lisbon starts to stage the fake kidnapping.  (Perhaps Rigsby doesn't even know it is fake during the episode.)

This would kind of make this episode like "The Mentalist - Greatest Hits" because it draws on a lot of elements and twists that we've already seen and would be a good farewell to Rigsby/GVP.  

Eh?  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Holy shit sunday is the last episode for both Rigsby and GVP!!!!!!!

http://www.tvguide.com/News/Mentalist-Owain-Yeoman-Amanda-Righetti-Final-Episode-Rigsby-Van-Pelt-1079561.aspx

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In a tweet from Karl Sonnenberg: "Production meeting time for 622. Written by Bruno Heller, directed by Chris Long. Not giving out the title on this one."

https://twitter.com/TA4TV/status/447052890448723968


Red?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on