Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

I just wrote a theory recently, #17866 [as a sarcastic joke!!], parodying "Casablanca" to make fun of what will be the final [and predictable] scene with Jane, Lisbon & Pike.

NEVER NEVER did I think these Mentalist writers would actually BE so mental LOL as to include "Casablanca" as part of Jibson symbolism....I mean, I just can't believe they referenced "Casablanca..." and seriously....SO CHEESY!

But I should have KNOWN they would....Heller & Co. have practically used EVERY last famous literary and film reference known to man, it seems...and though I wish I could be amazed by their use of mining previous material -- I am not.  They usually reference it badly....as a cliche or they just go absolutely nowhere new with it.  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Needless to now ask yourself questions that will never find answers. Just take it like that. There are films, books and songs are masterpieces, as well as then there are these antics. Do not get me wrong I was a big fan, but when you kill a story like that ... well ... you deserve all my contempt!
So my friends let go of everything, go ahead and dedicate yourself to what really deserves attention.

Who knows how to do, do it! Those who can not do, then end up writing a very banal love story.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This is how I faced off against red john, how he should have died, bruno heller ruined this show!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWrwq4MpFSw

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Piggy backing off the previous poster last episode was a metaphor for Jane and the Fbi. Its not a con its a sting!
I have always said Jane joined the Fbi for more reasons than hangin with Lisbon and boredom. He knows Rj had Fbi connections plus when Jane was inches away from Rj it was the Fbi who shut down Cbi and halted the investigation.
Who is Jane looking for ? Well at first i was sold that Marcus Pike was guilty as sin. Especially the way Jane looks at him. BUT i have a feeling Marcus Pike is hypnotized into loving Lisbon. I thought it was weird how fast he was drawn to her like he was under a love spell. But this could be attributed to someone making him feel this way.
My new suspect is none other that Wylie the Coyote!
Firstly Wylie just so happened to be searching for Jane during his lunch break and got himself put on the front lines in doing so. Shady.
Jane has took Wylie under his wing it seems and Wylie loves Jane kinda in an obsessed idolization way.
Also this struck me this week, Wylie could be Brett Styles son!!! He kinda looks like him right? Keep an eye out for the coyote...
Kim Fischer sucks. Weird is an understatement. She loves Jane like a lot. Also i still think her spying on Jane in Mexico and Abbott not knowing where Jane was in Mexico has still not been explained. Nobody has been able to explain it to me either. Why didn't she tell Abbott where Jane was?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For what it’s worth, I thought this was a great episode.

Let’s talk metaphors, shall we?

The grand jury is a metaphor for show.  The prosecutor is accused for being deceitful in order to ensure the defendant gets acquitted.  The jury is innocent but being led astray.  Jane says that it isn't that she is excluding or falsifying evidence but rather that the deceit is in how she tells the story.  She isn’t lying, but allowing the jury to believe something false by telling her story “halfheartedly” and “lacking confidence.”

We accuse Heller and co. of lying and falsifying clues about Red John when he gave us a disappointing reveal.  But, perhaps, his true misdirection is in the “halfhearted” way he has closed the Red John story and thereby lulling us into believing something that is false.  It’s not a con….its a sting.  ;)  (Ok, it is a con, but a good one.)

Speaking of halved hearts, if we are going to get any information about Red John it will be in “Black Hearts”.  Yes, the title is a reference to the black market hearts cut out of those poor women.  But, let’s not forget that in previous seasons the episodes didn’t always have “red” in them.  Sometimes it was just things that are usually red...like blood or roses.  Having obvious linkages between the title and the story in both yesterday’s and next week’s episodes distracts us from this.  

This whole human trafficking arc has me feeling uneasy and suspicious.  First “bow and arrow” and now a system of tattoos?  Both things were introduced awkwardly and both too obviously mirror the clues we got about the Blake Association. In “Brown Eyed Girls”, we briefly saw this Ridley fellow - we are meant to believe that he is the big baddie but I, as I usually am,  am suspicious.  

We will just have to wait and see.  We know that Red John had access to high risk women (from people like Jason Lennon and Miriam Gottlieb) and we don’t understand fully the circumstances under which he killed Lorelei’s sister.  There is potential for a tie-in of some kind with this arc.

Just so long as I don't have to endure Jane telling Lisbon to "get on that plane" in the finale episode, I'll be all right.  Not just because I'll be sad about them parting ways but because I could never accept such a heavy handed reference.  But Casablanca is a truly great movie.  If you've never seen it, you should drop everything and go watch it.  (Also, blanca = bianca = white.)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In the last episode of the season "Blue bird" the team investigate a cold case, maybe this cold case is about the "car crash" which lead to Bret Stiles taking over visualize, as from my memory that is the only such unsolved case that has been mentioned in the show, this could then lead to information about Red John confirming or disproving that he was Thomas, as Red John is known to have a visualize connection. Tell me what you think guys!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Anyone else want to kick Bruno Heller in the nuts after the last episode? Is he intentionally trying to piss off the fans who liked the Red Johns story! I think the character Patrick Jane is based on Bruno Heller because he has played a big long con on us all. 
We at least thought some of the Red John story would be answered with the trial but of course not, because Bruno Heller basically conned us all. .

I mean the ending was so disappointing, not the fact that the killer was Mcallister which was ridiculous anyway, but the fact that Heller didn't really answer any of the major clues that were dropped before hand. That for me is just terrible writing. Don't even get me started on the episode being leaked early and the fact that we could see Mcallister jumping through the window in the promo. That is such a great way to reward the hardcore fans of the show ! really the great Red John was caught because he is scared of Pigeons, i think it is just a lack of respect from Heller really





Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on