Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

First, thank you to those who have partcipated in my 
little informal survey and commented. 

I don't think The Mentalist is going to revisit the Red John storyline. In my mind it ended with 602, and it's up to my imagination how it went from there.

However, we did get a lot of great RJ scenes before then, so what are yours top 3 favorite RJ-related scene? A scene where they're talking about him counts.

Mine are

1) Blinking Red Light: when Patrick manipulates Panzer to insulting Red John on tv so RJ would kill him, and then RJ does kill him. That was extremely powerful and the last thing I imagined Jane would ever do.


2) The whole last part of the season 2 finale. *Shivers*

3) The end of Desert Rose (601) when RJ calls Patrick from Theresa's phone. "Sorry Patrick. Theresa can't come to the phone right now. Can I take a message..." And he's all casual. Awesome scene.

And of course there were many more great scenes, so what are your all favorites?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There was something about the Mentalist fandom (those who make an effort to watch the show regularly) that had me really confused. Why did so many not like the Red John storyline and were eager for it to end? Afterall, there were only a handful of RJ-centered  episodes in a season(not counting s6). The great majority of the episodes were Jane and CBI doing their thing solving the cases of the week. So why in the world were people so eager for it to end?
     And then I realized something. The majority (or at least the vocal majority)of the fandom are Jane/Lisbon shippers, and Red John was the greatest impediment to them getting together. So it did not matter if RJ was never mentioned in the episodes, as long as he was out there, Jane and Lisbon would not get together---whether it was because Jane was scared of RJ hurting Lisbon or whether Jane was so focused on catching RJ that entering in a romantic relationship was the furthest thing from his mind. Either way, the Jisbon shippers had a problem with it.
    So we can say that the fandom is/was primarily divided into two groups: those who watch for the relationships (especially Jisbon)  and those who watched for the Red John storyline.  
   I wonder if those fandoms can be divided among gender...with the majority of Jisbon fans being female and the majority of the RJ story fans being male. I don't mean to be sexist, since I'm female and was/am a huge fan of the RJ storyline (at least until 603 but that's a whole different topic).
  Anyway, I would like to conduct an informal survey. Obviously, everyone on this forum is/was fan of the RJ storyline, even if you don't like the way it ended. Would you please press the green button if you are male and the red button if you are female?
Thank you!





Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well, here I am, again waiting for a "Mentalist" episode, I'd sniffed ol' terokal glue like crazy, there's no hope unless there's an open finale. It's gonna be crime of the week and Abbot's secret crime arc as a background from here till "Lazarus". "Jisbon" is not working at all, that computer nerd is a wrong pathetic character and repeating that cheesy "love story" between partners is bad taste. Hope that "Wylie" or whatever his name is will be murdered, along with Vega and Cho who are all wasted fillers. Jane and Lisbon will be forced to leave, to run and hide while the real monster (not that surrogate Pink Joan) starts the final hunt.
None of this is gonna happen of course. I'm not Bruno fuckin' Heller or his shite team.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Brett Styles episodes usually have the word "HIS" in them.
I never knew why but maybe we will find out in two weeks.
We all know Styles said he would return, and i still contend a character of his stature would not die off camera.

"HIS Red Right Hand"
"The Blood on HIS Hands
"HIS Thoughts Were Red Thoughts"
And in two weeks...
"The Whites of HIS Eyes"

Fingers crossed..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I have been reading that there will be this new serial killer the finale will focus on, named Lazarus, right?
In this case, the writers are doing a good job keeping my hopes up, as St. Lazarus was the subject of a miracle of Jesus who restored him to life. The Lazarus Syndrome was even mentioned once in the Mentalist (season 2 episode 17) by...Rigsby.

My obsessed brain wants to see in Lazarus nothing more than a Red John restored to life for our greatest pleasure.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So the next episode is "little yellow house".
If anyone remembers that is what Jane said
Red John lived in on national television right before his family was killed.
Should be interesting...

Also the episode after that is "the white of HIS eyes".
I believe most of Brett Styles episodes had the word "HIS" in them.
The blood on HIS hands...i forget the rest...
There really hasn't been a big storyline on the show yet this season.
I am assuming Lazarus will be returning from the grave soon.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #18622 • By LordLeoric
Show this theory

  Guys, let me start this gently... I know most of you are feeling let down, or tricked by Bruno Heller and his screenwriters, but let me share my theory, or at least what I think the show has been trying to build up right from the start. Red John is and always will be a mask, no matter of the man behind that mask. Red John doesn't die with McAllister! RJ is an idea, it's a belief, it's that thing you follow on instinct not on facts. For all we know the sheriff might not even be the person behind that mask, and even if he was, the next one will take his place right away. All those things have been left for the viewers to get, ....to comprehend. And many of you in your hate just missed up on all those little things we got hunched. It is as if everyone expected a superman behind that mask ... an immortal man, not afraid of anything. Well.. here the writers hit the main idea, RJ can be afraid, can be desperate, once his mask is peeled off, once he isn't RJ anymore. This proves my theory in some ways.
  Just think about it, this is all I'm asking. In some ways, this is a brilliant end of the RJ saga, an open end which just makes you think, which has been the whole idea of the show.
  Just a mask...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on