Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

This is not a Theory or anything!


Just got some question for you guys ; - )

It goes way back, all thee way back to Season 1 EP 10 when we see a small flash back about Janes break down

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2oILijLCjU8

At 0:53, we can see a Red John smiley face inside jane's room when he was at that place, the smiley face is really messy but whatever? who do you think made it? Was it Red John that came to see Jane? or was it Jane that made the smiley himself?


please comment i would like to find this one out :-)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Lorelei wondered why Jane and Red John didn't become lifelong friends the moment they shook hands. This implies the first time Jane met Red John, they shook hands. Moreover, I believe the scene where Red John and Jane shook hands is of great importance, so important that it had to be included in the show. So possible off-screen handshakes are ruled out. It's the type of scene fans would like to go back and watch after Red John's identity is revealed. Luckily, the show includes the scenes where Jane first met every single one of the five remaining suspects.
 
He first met Stiles while he was recording a promotional video for the cult in Visualize HQ(Red All Over). No handshake here.
First met McAllister on a crime scene in Napa County(Red Hair and Silver Tape). No handshake.
First met Smith after investigating a crime scene(The Crimson Ticket). The CBI team is about to leave when Smith and his colleague arrive and end up fighting with Cho and Rigsby. No handshake here either.
He first met Bertram on a crime scene(Red Sky At Night). They shook hands.
First met Haffner after Lisbon's team was suspended in the beginning of the fourth season(Little Red Book). They shook hands.

So it's just Bertram and Haffner. Of course all this is based on the minimum competency expected from the producer, which has been questioned several times. Personally, after Red John's identity is revealed, I would like to go back and watch where he first met Jane. The handshake was a turning point, it has to be included in the show. Jane's emphasis on the handshake part and not just "meeting" would support my theory. The problem I face is similar to what Rosalind's description theories and Red John's age theories face; namely, why didn't Jane take them into account. Using Rosalind's description he can easily rule out Bertram. And knowing that Red John was a younger than 30 in 1988 would rule out Stiles. But Jane didn't do it, at least it looks like he didn't. It's possible he's trying to trick Red John into believing he's so far from catching him while he's actually closer than he anticipated. It's also possible the show is not flawless, but I highly doubt it, at least not on the scale of ignoring all of these data, but it's still a possibility.







Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Goodness, get over Partridge already! He is NOT Red John.
The man is dead. Think it
through.

For him to be alive, everyone on the scene of the crime must
have an IQ of a gold fish, the exact EMT to arrive at the scene must be
his minions, the exact doctor that received his body at the hospital
must be a minion, the exact coroner performing the autopsy must be a
minion, his next of kin must be involved with the scam (or if he is
without relatives, he would be sent for cremation, which means the
morgue attendants and funeral house workers must be his minions).

Do you all realize now how crazy that would be?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The Mentalist - Episode 6.08 - Red John - Press Release

Taken from: SpoilerTV http://www.spoilertv.com/2013/10/the-mentalist-episode-608-red-john.html#ixzz2jLa1jOdA 

“Red John” — Patrick Jane finally comes face-to-face with Red John, the serial killer he’s tracked since the madman murdered his wife and daughter. For 10 years, Jane has doggedly hunted his nemesis in his search for justice, on THE MENTALIST, Sunday, Nov. 17 (10:00–11:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm gonna die this episode.....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Cho is asian and Red john will kill him but it will turn out that RJ is godzilla and Cho's ninja friends will avenge cho by slicing red john in half with their ninja swords

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Am a long time reader but first time poster so apologies if
I am repeating info but am trying to add new positive insight to the Brett
Partridge theories.  Have watched The
Mentalist from the beginning and have enjoyed re-watching several of the
episodes to connect the “Red” dots so here goes…



1.     
 Believe
the writers are having a good time sending us messages which pertain to our
list of suspects.  In the conversation
between Wayne Rigsby and Kimball Cho in 6.4 “Red Listed”, they are discussing
reading studies on the Internet.  As Cho facetiously
promotes a ridiculous Internet study, he flippantly argues with Rigsby by
saying “I’m just telling you what the Internet said.”  Rigsby, trying to disagree with the silly
theory, emphatically replies with “Anyone can say anything on the
Internet.  It doesn’t mean it is true.”  That in mind, believe the writers are saying just
because we have read articles on the internet about Brett Partridge, or the
character we know as Partridge, is really dead, doesn’t mean it is true.





2.     
Per conversations between Patrick Jane and
Walter Mashburn, in “Redline” first aired 2/4/10, Walter says:  “Patrick, we’ve been this way before, let’s
go back.”  Patrick’s response is “Oh
please be patient.  See, the thing is
Walter, no matter how smart a plan you make, there is always someone smarter
who will see through it.  Makes it very
hard to get away with murder.”  Believe
this conversation can be the writers’ homage and complements to the
viewers.  For those of us who have
thought Brett Partridge was Red John from the beginning, the writers have to
throw us several curve balls to keep us interested and wondering if we were wrong
or were if we were really right that Brett Partridge is Red John.





3.     
With that in mind, the number one curve
ball from the writers was “killing off” Brett Partridge from the beginning of
the sixth season. However, as many viewers have speculated, and as the writers
have done in episode “Red Hot” from 11/4/10, not every upfront murder ends in
death.  At the end of the show, Patrick
gets to confront the killer who turned out to be Walter Mashburn’s enemy Yuri Bajoran.  Yuri, who had
supposedly died at the beginning of the episode, had staged his own death from
the beginning of the episode.  Smug Patrick,
who was sure from the beginning Yuri was not dead, says to him at his capture:  “Yuri Bajoran, you’re looking delightfully
not so blown up by a bomb.  Very clever
of you, I must say, no one suspects a dead man, well, almost no one.”  Patrick continues to prove his point of the
staged death when he says there was “a little DNA sprinkled everywhere to prove
you died in that explosion.”  So, with
the writers playing the undead death card before, don’t put it past them to
have done it, again.  Certainly with
Brett Partridge’s forensic/medical background, he would easily know how to
stage his own death with a little blood and DNA. 





4.     
Other items to point out
about the possible staged death scene of Brett Partridge:



a.     
If you watch this scene posted by
CBS on Youtube several years ago, you will see Brett Partridge wearing a
wireless headset which gives him the tools for making a clear handsfree phone
call while toying with a bloody knife:  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNNVF8rJjrw


 



b.     
Forensic agents have to have
medical training including doing autopsies. 
Believe the knife being shown at the end of 6.1 Dessert Rose is a
medical/surgical hook knife which is the kind of knife a forensic agent with
medical training might have in his tool kit. 
http://www.awltovhc.com/image-3300089-11044874?imgurl=http%3A%2F%2Fc.shld.net%2Frpx%2Fi%2Fs%2Fpi%2Fm...


 



c.     
In 3.3 The Blood On His Hands Kristina Frye has
been found with an IV puncture wound on her arm.  It would take some degree of medical training
to withdraw and IV of blood.


 



5.     
If it is Brett Partridge then it will be no
surprise to find out that the name Brett Partridge is a pseudonym (his name has
been changed to protect the innocent or the guilty).  Per Wikipedia, “According to Greek legend,
the first partridge appeared when Daedalus threw
his nephew, Perdix, off the sacred hill of Minerva in a fit
of jealous rage. Supposedly mindful of his fall, the bird does
not build its nest in the trees, nor take lofty flights and avoids high places.[1]”  With that tale in mind, could be symbolic for
Brett Partridge being the nephew of Bret Styles and he was thrown out of
Visualize due to his bad behavior but, since he is family, Bret Styles still
keeps up with him and protects him up to a point.  Would also be where Red John could have
learned from the master on how to draw people into his own cult.  Would even be willing to say that Ray Haffner
is Bret’s son, making him Brett’s cousin and has used his influences to protect
him as well as carry out some of his wishes, too.  Haffner does look like he could have posed as
a motorcycle cop to poison Sam Bosco’s secretary Rebecca as she is walking down
the CBI halls in chains.  If you look at
the processional of the motorcycle cop on the right side as they are bringing
her to CBI, he does resemble Haffner. 





6.     
Last but not least, as far as Tyger, Tyger goes,
maybe Partridge, aka Red John, has been saying those words to Patrick et al to
get them to look for the connection of corruption in the government that is not
Red John’s cult but instead Read John’s enemy. 
Would throw them off of his scent for a while and take out many of his
enemy’s.  Perhaps the Red John password
is Roll Tide for the Crimson Tide that Kristina Frye said to the waiter while
on her date with Patrick.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Not a RJ Theory. Watch the link at the bottom to remind yourself exactly what killing Redjohn means to Patrick. It's easy to get caught up in the high-paced action, and be disappointed by who or how. I hope this video puts things in perspective again.

I'll also make an awkward theory for entertainment...

RJ got Patrick's notes from the mental institution months ago. Patrick's first case, immediately after watching the Lorelei video, is from Redjohn accomplice, Bertram. The case of Cody Benbow. RJ picked Jane for this case for a reason. RJ could easily manipulate the case into a reality - he is a mentalist. Why is this case laid out for Jane? Well, after reading the notes from mental institution, RJ learns something interesting about Jane- a layer of Jane's guilt we never knew about. Jane on live TV taunted Redjohn to murder his wife. Not his child though. Jane's mistake was underestimating RJ's connections and how quickly RJ would act. And his child was killed. 

When Patrick stands in front of Cody Benbow's portrait. Its eerie. Eerie like the way Partridge stands in front of a Redjohn smily.

It almost makes you think... did Patrick orchestrate his wife's death the same way he orchestrated Panzer's? I mean, who goes on a talk show and badmouths a serial woman killer. Straight after the case, when Bertram deals with Patrick, his choice of words to describe himself is "Calculating and Duplicitous." If what I postulate is true, that would be an excellent taunt from Redjohn with his new knowledge.  

When Patrick talks to his daughter in the hallucination episode she says "Mom would not be happy," to which he replies "Well, the interesting thing about your mother is, its not your business..."

Bruno even asks after he's killed Redjohn "How does he live with what he’s done?"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bqMDqQ-nhlY

At 1:36 onwards, Patrick reads. It should get every Mentalist fan psyched for the Redjohn reveal! If you don't remember, Patrick wrote that letter himself.



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on