Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Summer Edgecombe

Summer Edgecombe
Suspected in 30 theories


This is not a waste of time. 

It is not that i do not want Xander Berkeley for the Red John Role, he played it absolutely well. And I admire him for that. However, there is something that i cannot stop thinking about. 

Red John is a show man, an artist, a psychopath, a true sadist. IF I AM RED JOHN, i will let Patrick Jane have a life before i reveal my real identity. How? Send Patrick Jane someone, let him believe that he is the real Red John. Let Patrick Jane kill that fake Red John. Now, Jane believes that he already killed the man who murdered his wife and daughter, and he’s getting his life back. Only to find out later, that he killed the wrong Red John again. And yes, it will be more painful for Jane.

I believe that this is the “RED JOHN STYLE”. 

We all know that the Red John saga does not end in season 6 episode 8. Yes, because Bruno Heller did not answer all our questions on how everything has happened like WHO IS THE REAL RED JOHN? If he is indeed Xander Berkeley, then please answer all our questions like: 

1.   Why on earth did he put CBI ron in almost all episodes in every season. What is his role? 

2.   What is Red John’s Real name? Is Roy Tagliaffero the real one, if not, why did he choose it?

3.   Where is waldo? Seriously? He appeared only in one episode of the first season. And then come back on the 6th season because Bruno Heller decided that he is red john. 

4.   What did Sam Bosco tell Patrick Jane before he died? 

5.   Who is the RED SWEATER guy at the end of Season 3? 

6.   How, When, Why did Red John started killing? 

7.   What made him become a serial killer? 

8.   How does he attract women easily? 

9.   How does he easily manipulate his followers? 

10.How was he able to get money for all his bloody projects? 

11.How is he related to Brett Stiles? 

12. How did he come up with the List? 

13. Why women and children? 

So many questions to answer Mr. Bruno Heller. I asked once, not to leave as hanging. 

We need answers. These are just my thoughts. I respect yours, Respect mine. 

Anybody wants to discuss anything about the show? 


Argue on this theory or rate it.


If he is a writer, then I'm a poet...

"Heller Heller in the night,
first we thought you were so bright..
why so much pretend ?
just to give us a crappy end!"

Argue on this theory or rate it.

First things first,

What were you thinking ?!?!?! 
I will never watch any of his shows anymore!!!


CBS...you ruined even more this crappy episode with the promo and the "not fake" video, you are the world's most idiotic guys on earth.

No one hacked anything, it was there, plain and simple, in the source code.

Glad some of you made http://www.red-john.info/
I really need to laugh out loud

Argue on this theory or rate it.

So those who have been fooled by the fake episode are still posting the same lame, "get over it it's real," posts. SO if you are so sure of yourself (and no full of doubt waiting for us to convince you otherwise), why are you still on this site? It is because you are not as confident about your remarks as you want us to think. Other wise you wouldn't be coming back to this site, hoping the page loads, and hoping we've given you a new nugget to give you hope.

The episode is a fake. If you disagree and you are not as pathetic as I now beleive you to be, then I would expect to not see you on a site that asks the question that you claim you already know the answer to. Fair enough?

Argue on this theory or rate it.

If your a little upset to RJ Conclusion join the twitter postings CBS will love this

Copy and paste on twitter. and help get this trending. writers and cbs wont be impressed just like everyone on here... social media. eh.


Red John is Thomas McAllister #McAllisterisredjohn #redjohn #thementalist #cbs @cbs @mentalist_cbs @officalredjohn @whoisredjohn @jimmygadd

Argue on this theory or rate it.

Oh, now THATS a REAL photo from the REAL episode:



Argue on this theory or rate it.
Follow us on