Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

The story of the couple of married assassins, Malcolm and Sandra Boatwright, in the McAllister's first episode, is similar at history of Timothy Carter, the Red John impersonator, and his wife Sally, in Strawberries and Cream/Scarlet Ribbons/Little Red Book. 
In Red John's Friends, Jared Renfrew
draw in the wall, before his death and with blood, the write: He is
Mar... That could be He is MacAllister, or not "He is Mar" but an
incomplete anagram as "l l c is mar...te", then "McAllister". Jared
could prepared this anagram when he was in prison; if Red John will kill
him, the killer would not have deleted the clue.

In Van Pelt file in Red Dawn (even if it is anachronistic, because it happened a few years after) there's the plot of part of McAllister episode, with the "redhead girls killer".

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I have done the theory #4446 (blablabla). But I have to correct many mistakes.First , im not going to pay attention to the photo I have seen. So lets discover who is RJ.

List of the SEVEN SUSPECTS:

-Brett Patridge
-Bob Kirkland
-Thomas McAllister
-Reede Smith
-Gale Bertram
-Bret Stiles
-Raymond Haffner

Clue #1: Red John kills people that investigate him. The only one that can do this is Patrick Jane.
So , if we count that , Bob Kirkland can´t be.
Now , the list is like this:

-Brett Patridge
-Thomas McAllister
-Reede Smith
-Gale Bertram
-Bret Stiles
-Raymond Haffner

Clue #2 Lorelei told Patrick that Red John hadn´t became friends since they shaked hands.So , Bret Stiles  cant be , because he is Patricks´s friend.
Now the list is:
-Brett Patridge
-Thomas McAllister
-Reede Smith
-Gale Bertram
-Raymond Haffner

Clue #3: Roselind Harker told Patrick that Red John is less than 6 fit tall:

Brett Patridge: 5 ´11
Thomas McAllister: 6
Reede Smith: 6´3
Gale Bertram:6´3
Raymond Haffner: 6´1

Only leaving:

Brett Patridge
Thomas McAllister

Clue #4: Red John´s best friend was a Sheriff (1x23) isnt it a coincidence that Thomas McAllister , one of the suspects , is a Sheriff. We dont know if he worked on Vizualize , so perhaps it could be Raymond Haffner.

BUT KNOW ... SHERIFF THOMAS MCALLISTER IS RED JOHN (OR RAYMOND HAFFNER)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just a thought.I know most of you believe that Sheriff Thomas McCallister isnt RJ and if he is it will be dissapointing.Anyway i dont know if he is RJ indeed but im pretty sure that he isnt just a Sheriff.If you pay attention in the conversation between him and Van Pelt at s01e02 especially when he says "I think you are drunk Mrs" you will see a man that tries to seduce Van Pelt(i dont know the reason and thats the key).I dont know if eventually McCallister will be RJ but the fact that he is on the list isnt random at all.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There are 2 theories I've read thus far that I'm confident are wrong. 

First, the earlier theory that Raymond Haffner is Rosalind Harker's brother doesn't make sense.  If so, why wouldn't Rosalind say that Timothy Carter was Red John when PJ brought her into the morgue?  That way, she would protect her brother and give PJ the mistaken impression that he killed RJ.

Second, no way Kirkland is RJ.  Just way too obvious and easy.  I don't buy the convoluted theory that he got plastic surgery, which is why Jason Lennon did not recognize him.  I actually think Kirkland is trying to kill RJ for himself, hence his obsession with the case.  I think RJ will kill Kirkland in the season 6 premiere.  Now, you are wondering, "well then how did RJ know the list of 7 suspects?"  I think PJ wanted Kirkland's guys to break in, so he would lead him straight to RJ.  However, I think one of the homeland security guys works for RJ and gave the information to both RJ and Kirkland.  

As of now I'm leaning towards Thomas mcallister mostly due to process of elimination.  I don't think it's brett partridge since he's too young, and I don't see how a lowly forensics guy can wield such clout.  I think PJ will start focusing on Bertram, mcallister, and haffner, and then go from there.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Is that McAllister with Bertram in Season 6 ?

http://www.spoilertv.co.uk/images/the-mentalist/Season%206/Promotional%20Episode%20Photos/Episode%20...



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think it's the sheriff Mc Allister. He is the sheriff of a small town.  In France, when we speak of a city outside of Paris, for example the campaign, said there was a smell of potato.Now, remember statements Rosalind Harker at the end of season 1.
Sheriff, you're surrounded.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm pretty sure that Bruno Heller had already introduced Red John in the first season (or by latest the second one), because he had no idea if the show would continue, and in the worst case, he would've wanted Red John to be atleast introduced as a person to the audience. Cross- referencing that fact with Jane's list, that only gives three names : 

1. Brett Stiles
2. Sheriff Mcallister
3. Brett Partridge

(A) Since Brett Stiles was the one who assigned Red John (the 'kid') to work in Elliston Barn (If you closely listen to Cooper on that episode), and since Partridge is the more obvious choice, that leaves only one man : Sheriff Mcallister.

(B) He was acting like a creep when he tried to escort Grace Van Pelt, so it could be obvious to guess that he could've kidnapped, raped and killed Miranda Martins.

(C) And this is the stupidest theory you could find,but Jane and Mcallister didn't become lifelong friends. You could see that the Sheriff was so pissed when he couldn't beat Jane in, after all, a normal game of Rock, Paper and Scissors...

(D) The guy who killed Rebecca had a Sheriff's uniform, and his body build resembled that of Mcallister.

(E) Simply, he's the one most people wouldn't give a second thought about, because he appeared in only one episode. The list could've contained Minelli, Masburn, or even Ron (ESPECIALLY Ron), and people would've really considered any one of them to be Red John (I did, myself, see #4298). But why, specifically, would Jane note down the Sheriff's name??

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on