Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Whether you think it is plausible or unlikely, tell me if this did not cross your mind. I know this would be a terrible way to end it, but...

Why do Mr and Mrs Rigsby have to leave the show, if the new regulations allow them to continue on the team and be a couple? Weren't you nervous when the walked in front of that 21-gun salute -- especially with that creepy General Custer fellow in the firing squad? Foreshadowing maybe?

I would not like it either folks, but what better reason for them leaving the show can you give now? Is one of them dirty? Is one of them (or both) going down? You can't put it past Red John. In fact, you should expect it.

Whatever happens, we know one thing for sure: Bye Bye, Newlyweds. 


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If you watched the promo for Red-Listed (Season 6-Episode 4) then you would know that the list Jane made is fake and that the men on the list we know of are in danger. He says that he knows someone was looking through his stuff, hence him smiling when he found the toothpick on the ground. I believe that this new list is going to be more narrow and it will have completely different people, which would be a major turn of events for the storyline of Season 6

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I don't think RJ is any of the remaining suspects of the list. I think Jane is one step ahead and knowing that accomplices if not RJ himself are in the CBI or its surroundings, and that everything they do and know there will be known by RJ... the whole list is a diversion.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Who's going down tonight? 

I will take voting unlikely to mean no one -- which is quite implausible, there's always a case to solve and almost always a murder. But perhaps we'll have a break from Red John given the festive occasion of Mr and Mrs Rigsby's wedding. 

But I'd love to hear your conspiracy theories for tonight's episode. A free grilled-cheese sandwich to whoever gets it right!

If you're in, vote PLAUSIBLE if you think there's a tragedy in store for someone, UNLIKELY if you think Heller's going to let us enjoy the wedding without disturbance. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

OK explain this please.

At the end of episode 6x01, Jane is walking outside Lisbon's office and looks inside, can't see her. He stops Ron right there and askes him if he has seen Lisbon. Ron was using his phono and yet he doesn't take even a second to answer "Nope, haven't seen her". Well most people (although maybe all people), are not in position to answer any question immediatly when using their phones. Not only that but although he's right outside Lisbon's office, he doesn't even bother to take a look, to take a glance inside before answering! How strange is that?

In episode 1x16 Van Pelt's boyfriend is after Jane for revenge. At the end he is taking Jane and Van Pelt out of the CBI building under a gun. They ran upon a guard and there Jane and Van Pelt try to run as her boyfriend shoots the guard and the guard shoots at the boyfriend. Jane and Van Pelt run to her car. At the same time the boyfriend shoots the guard down and is after them. This is where he sees a car leaving a parking spot and the driver passes right in front of the armed man. The driver takes a good look at the gunman and his gun! The driver is CBI Ron! He doesn't stop the car a little further to get out and help in any way. He just drives away. He doesn't do anything. What is strange is that he is supposed to be a CBI agend or something. He hears gunshots ( they took place a few second ago, can't be far), he sees an armed stranger running in the parking area, and doesn't seem to bother at all!
I know one would say many times in the movies we have seen such scene with drivers running away from armed men. But this is a CBI agend for god's shake!

Please help me understand the above 2. Is this the clue Heller said about episode 6x01? What do you think?


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

OMG! Big clue! I was watching Home alone and i saw that lady who was feeding birds in the park!! OMG IT WAS PARTRIDGE ALL ALONG, FOR ALL THESE YEARS!! I KNEW IT! Could this be the clue Heller was talking about? 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on