It's obvious: Kristina Fyre.
Stands on its own weight.

The list of seven provides so many possibilities to who RJ exactly is. Whether It be a character in one episode or a recurring one, it's interesting to think about who it may be. It's going to be a long summer.

Here's my thoughts:

RJ has killed about 25 people on his own, and I'm sure many others at his request. That's a lot of people for one person to kill, and even more family members who would miss them when they're gone. PJ cannot be the only person who is pissed at RJ...it's just not possible. Therefore, there must be others who want to get him and have atonement, retribution, revenge.

Enter Bob Kirkland.

Bob has lost someone because of RJ and he's pissed, motivated, almost to the point that PJ is, but not quite. PJ wants revenge, Bob is a federal agent, and he wants to catch him like any criminal agent would. He's studied the case for 5 years...he knows it well. He invokes the help of CBI, specifically Gale Bertram, wondering if they can trust PJ with information. He breaks into his room to see how far PJ has gotten without him knowing it. And yes...I think Lorelei is dead and know that Bob broke in after her death. In the end, Bob and PJ might work together to catch him...both motivated to be the ones that finally caught California's most notorious serial killer. Both want revenge; PJ won't kill known accomplices of RJ but Bob will. He has that hatred motivating him. PJ is trying to get his life back and rid himself of the horror.

As many people have pointed out, Bob is too obvious to be RJ...but what I want to know is why a Homeland Security agent is worried about a serial killer. A little out of his jurisdiction. He is more than likely a red herring. But not all herring fish are red, and not all Johns are red. So how did RJ get his name? The public named him...but why John? Why not Tom, or Bob, those are common? Perhaps John is a middle name. Brett John? Reede John? What about Raymond John?

PJ got really paranoid once the list was being whittled down. So he closed his door, worked in secret, let no one in, even Theresa, knowing someone at/with CBI is either RJ or working for him. RJ likes to hack into CBI, PJ knows this, and assumes that at some point, after learning about them shaking hands, his room will be broken into. So what do you do??? You track RJ, or make it look like you are tracking him, setting up data spread over a wall that rivals a neurotic vigilante. You test the theory with the toothpick, hence his elation when discovering it broken in half. And based on what was on the wall, RJ or his "friend" would find out what PJ knows and surmise what he believes is on PJ's list. RJ is always one step ahead of PJ but not this time...PJ has turned the tables, tricking RJ, who tells him the seven names which appear as suggestions of other suspects on PJ's wall. The name RJ also has seven letters in it for the seven suspects.

Interesting to note that all are law enforcement affiliated (except one), are kinda weirdos in their own respect, and are people of high power, which RJ craves. Many of the suspects can be cross referenced to either working together, present or formally, in the same cult group, or are from sister/cousin agencies in the federal government. Makes you wonder who knows what.

PJ's year in incarceration will be the reasoning for the happy memory being effectively pulled from his head. Hypnosis. Either in therapy or in the office. Someone who is faking their day job and is actually a true mentalist, unlike PJ, who doesn't believe in it, is RJ. And I haven't ruled plastic surgery with possible father/brother/family member of PJ being RJ, or the fact that some characters are so little seen on the screen. To me, any of them can be RJ.

PS
My only question is this: I read on here that Bruno Heller once said in an interview that when the show began, PJ was supposed to be RJ. Anyone have that article/link?

So simple Patrick Jane's father

To the maker of this Web-Site.

Please add a picture of RED JOHN Sheriff Thomas McAllister so that we can accuse him for being RED JOHN.

If Sheriff McAllister is RED JOHN I would be very dissapointed, because we had this in the series "Profiler" already.

Hey guys

This is more like an observation than a real theory.
I my opinion i have no doubt that the video with Lorelei is made by her and PJ.

And i think i have multible proof for my theory:

1.: PJ tells Lisbon that the list contains seven names before he is given the disk. I does not tell her that he has a "list", he tells her that he has "a list of seven". The odds are really really low that RJ has the exact same list af PJ!

2.: If Lorelei really are dead, then the video is made before Kirkland breaks in at PJ's place. That means RJ must have known that PJ would end up with the 7, witch either makes have a genious or PJ (witch i highly doubt). This means that either has PJ and Lorelei made the video before she died, or she is in fact not dead!

My best guess is that this is done by the mastermind of PJ to protect Lisbon or who else might get hurt. I also think that this rules out Lisbon as an RJ accomplice. Because if she was, she would have to go to RJ right after she saw the video, she would also know that the tape is fake.

I think PJ knows who RJ is, but he has to be sure before making his move. I also do not believe that Lorelei is dead!

I'm not sure who Red John is, it could be anybody really, but some things really irk me about certain characters.

Gale Bertram: In one episode where he talks about his poker game with Lisbon he says "gutted" him.
Also, in the same episode, but in an earlier scene where he was mad because he kept losing and Lisbon said that it was just a game he said: "You don't believe that" as if he was reading her.

Brett Partridge: This guy irks everybody, but what REALLY irks me is the fact that in the pilot, he said that Red John painted his face with a rubber kitchen glove. How could he know?

Walter Mashburn: He's in a "relationship" with Teresa, and Teresa is Jane's so I'm guessing that it'll be like O'Laughlin.

Kristina Frye: She knows too much and she didn't get killed, but abducted instead? I think she's one of the people Red John uses to keep an eye on Patrick.

Bob Kirkland: Now this guy is just an obvious Red John associate. He probably broke into Jane's place to confirm if Red John's list and Jane's were the same. If they weren't, he would've told Red John about it and consequently, Red John might have not given the video to Jane.

Ellis Mars: He is Mar

Rosalind Harker: She should've known that "Roy Tagliaferro" brought in a dead body, but she acted as if she didn't? That's totally not suspicious at all.

Bret Stiles: How did he know where Kristina was?

I'm not sure who Red John is, it could be anybody really, but some things really irk me about certain characters.

Gale Bertram: In one episode where he talks about his poker game with Lisbon he says "gutted" him.
Also, in the same episode, but in an earlier scene where he was mad because he kept losing and Lisbon said that it was just a game he said: "You don't believe that" as if he was reading her.

Brett Partridge: This guy irks everybody, but what REALLY irks me is the fact that in the pilot, he said that Red John painted his face with a rubber kitchen glove. How could he know?

Walter Mashburn: He's in a "relationship" with Teresa, and Teresa is Jane's so I'm guessing that it'll be like O'Laughlin.

Kristina Frye: She knows too much and she didn't get killed, but abducted instead? I think she's one of the people Red John uses to keep an eye on Patrick.

Bob Kirkland: Now this guy is just an obvious Red John associate. He probably broke into Jane's place to confirm if Red John's list and Jane's were the same. If they weren't, he would've told Red John about it and consequently, Red John might have not given the video to Jane.

Ellis Mars: He is Mar

Rosalind Harker: She should've known that "Roy Tagliaferro" brought in a dead body, but she acted as if she didn't? That's totally not suspicious at all.

Bret Stiles: How did he know where Kristina was?