Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Great! In Nova Scotia here. For those wondering WHICH episode is airing, I can confidently say that it is NOT the one leaked! This doesn't even look like the promo at the end of episode seven.

In fact, there's a lot of law office scene in here.

In fact, that gal who played the nurse on ER all those years is in this episode. Seems like she's a lawyer or something.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In my opinion, there are only two characters who Jane has battled to any degree all his life, himself and his arch enemy. These two opponents have remained central to every move he has made. Born into carny servitude for his father, his eventual emancipation and accention by marriage, his challenge and downfall and path of vengence. Personally I don't think his enemy has been a stranger Moriarty type character, or that I hope not because any character to oppose him must have more off everything that Jane has, to fulfill the arch enemy status. None of the suppose candidates so far have enough charisma to charm a goat let alone an army of martyrs. Beside his perpetual need to walk his path of vengeance, there is a central deep seated imbalance in his character which revolves around his father who made him what he is. I think his arch enemy should be Alex Jane, who has manipulated the master manipulator throughout his whole life including either becoming RJ, manipulating or enlisting him to bring the Boy Wonder full circle. Betrayal is paid with betrayal especially in tribal cultures like carnival folk. Alex Jane is his ultimate opponent and the most difficult to kill, all others he could execute with extreme prejudice including his colleagues and the one he has not calculated for. Personally any other character would be an anticlimax.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Guys,latest news!!!!!

The real Red John.

comfirmed!!!!!!!!!!!!!

the leaked episode was fake!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

http://vimeo.com/30395188

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

just before the show start... and if the leaked episode was real but..... just the first part of the role episode???

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

One of you creative writers out there seriously need to capture this whole absurd Red John circus that has played out here and elsewhere in the media leading up to tonight. (paging Christopher Guest!!!!;p) I am literally crying from laughing so hard from reading the exponentially hilarious comments in the days leading up to and including today (btw, today's winner for me has to be "Red Johnson-The porn version." Priceless.) ... Please know, that I am in no way disparaging anyone's theories-- I've really enjoyed them all. The really funny part for me-aside from the occasional bit of porn-themed snark--has been the whole game being played out with us, with the bogus episode, and the ensuing, "they leaked the Red John episode!!" "Is it real? No it's fake!" Can't be fake, that's ridic..." "Hey RJ's a pigeon's biatch!" In any case, it's been a fun ride and I'm going to miss it after today.

So...the story begins like this.."I registered this domain name calked 'whoisredjohn.com'....." That should get you started. :) Have fun....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

OK, the real episode is just upon us now. So just doing a recap of the silly absurd cheap and so on things I 'won't accept from tonight episode.
Feel free to contribute in the comments! This is my beginning list.

1. Brett Partridge is alive. Unacceptable from ep .1-2, totally unacceptable after Cho visits the morgue.

2. RJ are two persons.

3. Some scenes filmed just to deceive the viewers.
For ex. if we find out that the Bertram is a good guy and didn't actually killed the barman.

4. The twist "he just pretended to be pretending he was pretending to..."

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on