Who is Red John?

Theory #15086 • by Smartest_Idiot

Suspect

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

I read these on IMDB and I approve of this messages:

"..Patrick Jane is responsible for the death of Ray Haffner and Brett Stiles. 

He brought four people, none of whom he knew for certain were guilty of anything, in the vicinity of a serial killer, knowing fully well that the situation could potentially get explosive

Yeah, he didn't detonate the bomb. But he might as well have. Little did Ray Haffner know what fate had in store for him at Jane's house. He probably had plans for the day. Maybe he was going to spend some time with, I don't know, his wife and daughter? As for Stiles, some of you might argue he wasn't a saint, but really, what did he really do that made him deserving of being blown to smithereens? I don't remember anything, except that he swindled a lot of people. 

So yeah, I hold him responsible for the death of two innocent people. Thoughts?"
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"
I'm glad you brought this up. I thought I was the only one who hated Jane for doing that. 

If I have to be brutally honest, I'll be and say this - Jane is a disgusting human being. He's a hypocrite, a selfish man with no respect for anyone who breaks his own set of rules and morals, and he never ever considers anyone better than him. He was even worse before RJ killed his family, because he was a thief, and he preyed on poor, broken widows and people who lost their loved ones. I don't care if that was all his jerk father's fault, he made his own choices. 

I can't even imagine that kind of person finding a person to fully love, especially such a pure, beautiful person like his wife. He's an egotistical jerk with delusions of grandeur no less than RJ. 

So, we have this truly evil person (RJ) who has no redemptive qualities, and he did deserve to die BUT Jane was not the one to talk. At this point, jane disgusts me even more. 

And what pisses me off even more, is that the writers never acknowledge how bad Jane truly is. Sure, they portrait him like a not-so-good guy, but they still seem to justify everything he does because he has the right to. 

No, Jane, you're not the only one whose families and loved ones got killed by RJ and you're not the only one with the right to kill him, but you still thought so. So, F you, you selfish prick!"

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[Stiles and Haffner] aren't the only people he has gotten killed in his pursuit for vengeance. The list is very long. Frankly, he doesn't seem to even care.

Link: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1196946/board/thread/222562519?p=1


Don't get me wrong. I love Patrick Jane, but we the viewers are so sympathetic to his cause that we have disregarded the lives that he has indirectly taken.

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on