I actually always kind of thought it was Patrick Jane. I thought maybe he has some kind of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde thing going on. I knew that wasn't necessarily reasonable since the evidence suggested it was someone else. So I prepared myself to be disappointed. Seriously, though. Tonight's episode was terrible!! The whole series has been building to this one night, and Red John fell for the let-me-show-you-something trick. A pigeon. Red John was essentially beaten by a pigeon. It was lame that the episode had so much running. And how could McAllister get so far with that gunshot wound??? And his being an older man did he seriously have that much endurance??? I will say that it was SUPER creepy when McAllister did that Red John voice in the chapel. Overall all the episode was a terrible disappointment.