Why Rigsby is not Red John; If you want a respectable Theory , you have to cover plot holes, as well as interpret clues. Answer ALL of these or Rigsby isn't Red John. You can't just glaze over these things and say "every theory has plot holes," because that just proves YOUR theory isn't waterproof.

......................................

When Jane talks to Red John's voice in the limo in the finale of season 4, Rigsby is in handcuffs. The voice cannot be pre-recorded as it gives real and relevant responses to Jane. Explain.

Season one finale: How is Rigsby luring Jane to the farm, where he is sipping tea, when he is actually riding with Cho?

If Rigsby is Red John, why is he killing farm workers at the age of 10. These farm workers were bound by the hands, shot and dragged into the farm, so Rigsby must be one strong 10 year old to overpower these men. The killer dropped a high school class ring, furthermore Rigsby graduated high school at the age of 10 or below.



.....................................



Last of all, how do any of Jane's plans reflect he wants to catch Rigsby?

I don't know if you'll ignore this, or weasel out of answering these, but if you can't, stop saying you're being victimized because you think Rigsby is Red John.Your theories just aren't waterproof, it's just a mash of clues you put together in a kitchen blender. Where's my theory, you may ask? Focus on this one right here and I'll make a theory right here! :)