I think we interpreted the 5th season ending wrongly. The writers want us to think that red john is still a step ahead of red john and what not but what I think is that Patrick Jane wants Red John to feel that way. By making that list and letting red john "predict" it correctly, he has made red john more cocky and desperate to prove that he is the best. As red john put it himself that he will start killling again..and that is the window jane needs to watch his suspects even closer and wait for a mistake to happen. Of all the things we know about patrick jane, one is sure: he is smart as hell and this time it is red john who has fallen for his trap. 
Patrick jane victimized himself to lure rj out.