Who is Red John?

Theory #3937 • by Mentalman

Suspect

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

Not accusing anyone in particular but I wanna say I agree with the post a couple below me about Lorelei maybe beng alive. Youtube the scene where she is dead and it doesnt look right, she looks asleep, with very little blood, Kirkland is watching her closely (could easily be in on it, seems he has to be a disciple at least). It does not look like the other RJ murders and Jane reacts in a very suspicious way. He surveys it closely and then tries to get out of there quickly by saying "she had it coming"(maybe to not give away what he knows to Lisbon?) Heller loves twists like this, and so its not unthinkable that Jane discovered RJ's plan and countered with a fake list. Other evidence to back her possibly being alive is when Jane and Lisbon are talking he says "if we assume Lorelei is telling the truth.." rather than "if we assume Lorelei WAS telling the truth.." shes dead right? I doubt thats just a mistake. Also when they are talking about why Jane cant tell Lisbon who is on the list he says I cant because one of them is inside the CBI. The final list has two CBI agents, Haffner and Betram, so that doesnt make sense. Plenty of reasons to think the list is fake. If anyone has any explanation for these mishaps Id like to hear cuz it doesn't seem right that the writers just made a mistake that big

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on