S05 E07 - At the End of the episode, PJ bumps into Robert(Bob) Kirkland:
BK: Sorry mr. Jane.
PJ: Do I know you?
BK: No...but I know you.
then he smiles and leaves.
S05 E08 - Lorelai tolds Patrick:
PJ: I am nothing like him..
L: How would you know? I know!
L: I only wonder why the TWO of you didn't become life long friends
the moment you shook hands. [S05 E07]
Then at the end of the episode, after PJ crashes the car, he can hear Kirkland, who give some instruction on the radio.
PJ makes a weird face and ask Lisbon:
PJ: Who's that guy?
L: Don't talk, help is on the way.
How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely