Just trying to clarify what I initially said a few posts back. Although I do not think it is possible that Jane is RJ (based on different instances when they are in the same place at the same time or different places at the same time...unless disciples acted as RJ during those times). I think that there is some relationship between Lorelei and Patrick that has already been established. Lorelei seems completely comfortable with Jane , although she really does not know him, she seems to care about him much more than someone would care about someone they just met. Given what we've seen from her character and learned about her from her mother, Lorelai seems like a strong person and doesn't seem the type to just sleep with Jane because RJ told her to (which made me think that this wasn't the first time she'd met Jane whether he was aware or not). She seems almost familiar with his antics (like when she finds out that he lead police to believe she kidnapped him) and expresses frustration with him as if she holds the answer to everything but just can't bring herself to tell him (saying how alike he is with red john but doesn't even know it...I think people may be taking the "when you shook hands" too literally ). Again, there are so many things that make it virtually impossible for Jane to be RJ.. but I can't help thinking in the back of my head that Jane has some sort of personality disorder and is playing the part of both Jane/RJ, with Lorelai being Rj's lover, but in love with both personalities = Why she refuses to believe that Rj murdered her sister because that would mean Jane did it.. and also why she is so comfortable with him and does not try to escape from him. Also could make sense as to why she is so frustrated with Jane when he tries to deny being like Red John...saying she would know, seeing as she would have had extensive contact with both sides/personalities of Jane.