Who is Red John?

Theory #6198 • by Boontee

Suspect

Ray Haffner

Ray Haffner
Suspected in 875 theories

ARGUMENTATION

Hello everyone.

First I just want to say that I totally ignore Bruno's words because, he won't sold and spoil his show in media.

I have a problem with the list of the seven name. Some of them don't fit the clue we already have. So why PJ place them on that list anyway. Either, this list is bogus and the real RJ is not on it (objective is to create a trap with this list), either the list contains the real suspect on it and we can eclude Sheriff MacAllister, Smith, Bertram, Stiles leaving Haffner, Kirkland and Partridge or some of the clues we have, are, totally or partially, wrong (age, physics,...).

If some of the clues are wrong this may be because RJ is in fact several person. This theory explains ubiquity but have two major problem. First, I think we have already know if Rosalind Harker description in episode 1x23 was not correct and second RJ profile seems to descripe one person only and do not have major contrast (like two personalities in one). So for me that's wrong.

If the list is accurate, that means :
     -Sheriff MacAllister is out : don't fit with the description, don't seem to be manipulative but he can whistle... (could be a followers)

     -Smith is out : don't fit with the description, is not able to manage anger (could be a followers)

     -Bertram is out : don't fit with the description, don't seem very intelligent (could be a followers)

     -Stiles is out : would have been the perfect RJ but don't fit with the description. But he is for good close to RJ (could be some kind of a mentor).

     -Haffner is in : match description, can whistle, is kind of strange, shakes hand with PJ and don't become a friend. Is asking about the case (clue or not?!? not sure) Visualize member, ex CBI and FBI (have some relation). Is relatively low rank so he have more flexibility. have the motive => He is best suspect but maybe too best

     -Kirkland is in : match description, shakes hand with PJ and don't become a friend. But base on 6x04 promo he is not RJ because he torture PJ to have information (could be a followers)

   -Partridge is in : match description, is very strange, is in CBI (close to the case), is asking and following a lot RJ but doesn't shakes hand with PJ on screen (but we can assume they did it on screen; we don't have to take this clue literally I think)  and seems to be dead.

And finally, if the list is bogus, either the seven are RJ's followers or they are completly innoncent. This tell us something about PJ, if they are followers then PJ is cleaning up and approching RJ, if they are innoncent then PJ wants RJ and doesn't matter about collateral damage.

But then who is RJ :

     -PJ himself : in a sort he is because RJ is the perfect opposite of PJ (the evil twin -metaphorically-). He match perfectly and we cannot exclude him but in my personnal oppinion the show doesn't prepare us about this possibilities so it would be a too much artifical twist and what would is motive be?

     -PJ's hidden brother : could be but in 6 season we never had a clue about a brother of PJ so this would also be too much artifical.

     -Alex Jane PJ's father : would be too old to match RJ's description and isn't present enough in the show

     -Lisbon, Van Pelt, or other woman: we are looking for a caucasian man. (could be followers)

     -Cho : we are looking for a caucasian man. He could have been but he is too straight and a bit too young and friend with PJ.

     -Rigsby : too young, is friend with PJ (but is Lorelei saying the true when she says they are not friends...)

     -CBI Ron : drink tee, match description, is strange, always present since the beggining, has a ring in the same place than RJ. Doesn't shake hand with PJ. We don't know much about him so we can't exclude him => He is a good suspect and I don't understand why he isn't on PJ's list maybe because he is PJ's number one suspect.

     -Walter Mashburn : match description, has a lot of ressources, is intelligent and manipulative. We can exclude him execpt maybe because of the fact he isn't close to PJ and the case.

And if an other person is RJ, I will be very surprise and Bruno Heller will have a lot of job to sell me that.

So my number one suspect is Ray Haffner, followed by CBI Ron and Partridge.

Sorry for the very long post and for my english...

See you







How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on