Right, so we have a conspiracy on our hands. We know Bertram, Smith and McAllister are involved, probably Haffner, but what about Stiles? He has no links to law enforcement, so why would he be a member of a secret club? 

My guess is that Stiles Visualize collective is feuding with the Tyger Tyger club.

My other guess is that McAllister is running the show, which would probably make him Red John.