Women are the solution to this, which one of the suspects are capable of totally charming women and making them fall for him?

Absolutely not Partridge(creepy), Reede Smith(too fat). Probably not McAllister(too old, redneck), Kirkland (slimy), Haffner(no charm, stupid)

Brett Stiles and Gale Bertram could be charming but a bit too old to really pick up chicks all over.

So the list is fake, you need to open your eyes and find the real charmer in this series. Who even managed to get Lisbon into bed...