Who is Red John?

Theories of Hellfire (7)

I'm just gunna pretend the mentalist ended with Timothy carter being red john. Fuck macallister.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm almost hoping this show gets cancelled, the whole awkward jisbon thing is driving me mental(ist).
Jane and Lisbon do not have romantic chemistry and franu it's kinda gross. Also fuck heller for this weeks episode I was all excited thinking we'd get some rj answers. But nooooooo, honestly I hardly watch the episodes anymore I just press play and play games on my phone, it's so full and tedious now, blah. Heller needs a twitter so I can angrily tweet at him everyday. And also why is the whole cast so excited that rj is dead in every interview?
How about no?
I want rj back or atleast no dam jisbon, or else I'm done with this fucktarded show.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This whole jisbon thing needs to fuck off, they are trying so hard to force romantic chemistry that was never there. K fine I'll accept rj isn't coming back, but jisbon ? No thank you. I'm really over this show and the crappy writing.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #17476 • By Hellfire
Show this theory

I really hope volkner comes back! And that he's behind the murders

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Even though Red John is dead, his disciples and the Blake Association are still out there. Will we hear from them again?
Heller: I never say never, but I would say I think the audience and the story demands that we step away from that trope for a while. The trouble with these sorts of stories where you're playing tricks on the audience, with who-is-it mysteries, is you can get way too mysterious. There are people who said all the way along that Patrick Jane is Red John. When you've got that kind of elaborate thinking out there, it's dangerous to come back to that story unless you're coming back full force, because then maybe will start thinking, "Oh, maybe Red John's not dead." Red John is dead.



Dam it heller, I assure you the audience does not want you to "step away" from rj.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

When Bruno said we would all be disappointed with the rj reveal I thought he meant it would be partridge since most of us were expecting that, not that it would be mccalister, I think Bruno just wanted to shock us the most and in that regard it was a twist, as stupid as it was we should be glad he didn't end it in a even more ridiculous way, I mean he could have picked Lisbon or Rigsby. So let's all just be thankful it wasn't one of them, and hope that Bruno might give us another rj plot line.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So u was watching "the red barn" and at the end jane says he has 2164 people he's shaken hand with since his wife and daughter were killed 807 are women which he excluded and 949 were men that he had brief encounters with and never saw or heard from again so that leaves 408 names now jane only met mccalister once ? Wouldn't he have been excluded from his lost? Along with the other 948 people so why would Jane just suddenly think it's mccalister after he had already excluded him, I don't think Bruno planned any of this but sadly I think we all need to probably accept that the rj reveal was real even if it was stupid.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on