Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Reede shortened to Red, for when he was on the visualize farm.  He wanted to be called Red.  John just like smith means regular bloke.  He claims to be a low man on the totem pole, but he is higher ranking than McAllister.  He can tell MCAllister what to do.  In an interview with a judge present, he flipped out at Jane.  He wanted to just get rid of Jane, because he is Jane's antagonist.  Reede Smith created Red John with the first murders @ the Red Barn - on the visualize farm.  He got visualize to help him cover the murders up; he sold himself into Stiles' debt.  As payback, Stiles orders other members to force McAllister to cover up the mistake Reede Smith has made.  McAllister is the cleaner for Stiles' mafia.  As an officer, he was able to protect himself by finding out information that only police knew.  He uses what they know to create the perfect patsy.  His temper is what makes him really guilty looking.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I am getting that old buzz back for the mentalist! Not because of the episodes of the new beginning though,they have been very normal, very average episodes. But the fact that nothing has been explained regarding the Red John saga and the fact that Red John hasn't been mentioned once in the new episodes, leads me to believe that RJ is not dead and will return. I would be really happy if that happened, because it really gives the series a meaning. At the very least I hope the series finds a new main storyline pronto, (even if it is not RJ) in the next episode, because this crime of the week stuff is pretty standard and old. 
By the way, I didn't hate the fact McAllister was Red John ( at the moment at least) ,I hated the episode and the way they went about the reveal. It was bullshit as we all know. But I liked the fact that they chose a guy who was different from the other suspects: He was the only one who was relatively friendly with Patrick. I thought their scenes together were very entertaining and had good chemistry,apart from the terrible 6x08 episode. Bertram was a boring byrocrat and Patrick never liked him. Jane almost got Haffner fired. He thought Stiles and Visualize were a brainwashing cult. Smith was almost a stranger to him. He didn't know Kirkland very well. Patrick was very rude to Partridge. He never joked around with Partridge. But of course none of this mattered really in the end because the episode was crap.

I hope Heller makes up for it. I am still rooting for Haffner to be Red John and I would like the visualize connection explained.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Thomas McAllister is old enough to be located in police position around the time of Red Barn.  He is related to the true leader of Visualize.  McAllister is either the son of Visualize's former leader or another type of relation.  He decided to start killing Visualize members to test himself.  He may have covered for the ex-leader (executed) of visualize (if he is not it) by showing up to help make it go away.  He may have taken the blame for the killings, and he could be covering his tracks or someone he cares about.  Robert Kirkland was onto Visualize as a Red John associate, and he ended up going crazy.  He killed people, because he thought they knew who red john is.  What he was trying to do was find his brother who he believes joined Visualize.  Brett Stiles supposedly had the sheriff investigating Timothy Farragut's (original Visualize guru) death executed, because it was staged to look like an accident.  Lisbon's mom was killed by a drunk driver, and Timothy Farragut's (ex leader of Visualize) fatal accident involved alcohol.  There is a small chance that those two are related.  However, Farragut's death was ruled an accident.  Somebody wanted retribution for Stiles executions.  Red John is possibly someone struggling against Visualize.  Jane offers Red John a chance to kill Stiles, but he must be sacrificed - or there is no deal.  Jane can make it happen, but Red John has to die for killing his wife and daughter.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

     I'm now 100% that McAllister was not Red John           are you convinced beyond a shadow of a doubt that McAllister was Red John?    I'm not ....not even close          McAllister didn't act like Red John he acted like someone who was being forced through BA to impersonate Red John and kill Jane .......instead his fear of birds gets him shot and he starts crying, runs away  and collapses          claims to be a psychic???? ...........fuckin calls 9-1-1???   LMFAO                     look back to Timothy Carter   when he was "playing" Red John he told Jane he was going to retire and he was giving Jane advice about moving on and forgetting  but instead Jane shot him dead in public      Red John wanted to give him some peace of mind and help him move on     by the end of season 4 Red John wants Jane to join him       and when RJ planted a fake Red John on the list of 7 knowing that Jane would probably get the best of him and think that he got his revenge and move on with his life and find peace and finally be happy   and Jane did ......for two years         why did he really come back?   he knew Abbott was going to fuck him over   he wanted to work for the FBI      I think within the two year time jump Red John reveals himself to Jane now that Jane has his guard down and is relaxed      taunts him and just leaves  while Jane vows to hunt him down   The Real Red John just laughs at him      gone             then after a few more new beginning murder of the week episodes   there will be a flashback episode that shows what happened at Jane's house before the explosion and what really went on during those two years      the rest of the season is Patrick Jane and the FBI vs the Real Red John        the average viewers and the Jisbons get to see a RJ-less Mentalist for a handful of episodes      and the creative team behind the show get to do something new       but let's face it Red John is The Mentalist  and without him there is no show       I can feel the set up      there is no way they can keep up this new beginning story till the end of the season without Red John coming back      RJ sent in McAllister as another Timothy Carter to give Jane some peace of mind       I think the Rigsby's have something to do with this and when Red John returns Jane will have the FBI behind him and not the corrupt CBI that RJ owns      

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I've never really liked any "List of 7" suspects for RJ, that is individually speaking BUT...as a collective whole, they might all just add up to RJ quite well [The whole is greater than the sum of it's parts]

WHAT IF Rebecca Anderson's RJ is not the same as Lorelei Martins RJ.....WHAT IF:


HAFFNER committed the 1988 Visualize Barn murders...because he was there at the time, a troubled youth, and is connected with Visualize.  Do we have ANY information about McAllister's connection with Visualize?

PARTRIDGE killed Janet and Carter Peak...because it SURE looks like Partridge in the picture, not McAllister at all

MCALLISTER...killed Jane's family [as well as a few others]  because Jane killed the man he believed killed his family, and I believe that much is true

KIRKLAND TWIN was Rosalind Harker's lover..because McAllister doesn't fit this bill and we know the least about Kirkland Twin, but enough to know he fits her description exactly, especially the "smells of pine" part given his barn is in woods

BERTRAM, I think, went to see Sophie Miller -- but it could have been the other "whistlers" HAFFNER or MCALLISTER

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LihOPlJQq7w

Best scene in the series so far 3:13 to 3:23     

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If Timothy Carter was a fake Red John than why can't McAllister be a fake Red John?                                             get over it???  it's only been 3 episodes and the season isn't even half over you funkin dumb cunt                                       I bet you watched episode 11 with all your cats and was captivated by the Jane romancing the blonde story and was so shocked she was the murderer you dropped your knitting needles           you have the balls to come on a web site called WHO IS RED JOHN? and call the people who are posting theories about who Red John might be pathetic     go fuck yourself       better yet stop hoping for the Jisbon storyline nobody wants and go suck a bowl of dicks              







                                                                                                     
 
 















LOL 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on