Just something to toss into the mix.
Reede Smith anagrams:
"Theme is red"
"The red is me"

While he seems to have too quick of a temper to be Red John, he was conspicuously absent when Loralei was removed from CBI.

Lorelei Martins is not dead. She is with RJ, on or against her will.

Rosalind Harker has something to do with the killings. She knows more then she tells.

Kristina Frye might be involved somehow. Her disappearance was strange. Although, last time she was seen in the CBI, talking with Jane, so they wouldn't just let her go like that. They're probably keeping her somewhere. (mental inst, etc).   

Gale Bertram and Bob Kirkland have nothing to do with RJ. Think they're working secretly aside from PJ, against RJ. Kirkland killing Lennon was really strange and somehow proves the opposite of this theory about him, but we'll find out in season 6 about that.

Bret Stiles and Brett Partridge are the key for the RJ mistery.

PJ knows much more about RJ then he shows. Think he's already done something twisted and tricky (the toothpick, Lorelei Martins being dead, the CD, the list, ...) who knows.

Just one question, how can red john be a woman since he raped lorelai's sister?

You will never find me, no matter how many silly theories you may come up with.

Best of luck,
Red John

I think that 7 suspect list is fake!

My suspects are:

1.Dr.Wagner
2.Alex Jane(Patricks father)
3.Virgil Minelli


1.Dr.Wagner
-seen in Pilot
-he is a doctor
-In Jail - perfect alibi(Red John could put a double in prison or something like that)
-Nobody suspects him
-fits age


2.Alex Jane(Janes father)
-if he was RJ it would be very interesting
-he is maybe too old


3.Virgil Minelli
-Fits age
-was a CBI bosss


I THINK THAT DR.WAGNER IS RED JOHN

Red John finally seen, although he stated many times that He could not be seen
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=e0k8p2&s=5

CASE CLOSED!!

I have narrowed my list of suspects.  Red John is definitely one of the following:

Gale Bertram
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Raymond Haffner
Brett Partridge
Sheriff Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith

Ive also definitely ruled out Patrick Jane and every other suspect not on the list above.