Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister Reede Smith
Reede Smith Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

That Red Lutz is even crazier than Stoopkid, who at least is not rude.

What a moron thing to say: "if you think Red John is dead then don't come to this website". Well I'm sorry but some people want to talk about what's happening on the show after Red John's death. Yes, the website's name is Who is Red John because when it started we didn't know who Red John was. Now we know so the website's name doesn't matter anymore.
This page should be about the show now not 'who is Red John'. I bet in 5 years time some people here will still be sure that RJ was Rigsby or Van Pelt or whatever.

Red  John was Sheriff Thomas McAllister, the sheriff of Napa County, portrayed by Xander Berkeley whether you like it or not!
Lol, why is it so hard to accept now that the whole show has moved on!?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I am known on this website under a couple of names, RedJohnLutz, Stooopkid and Spammer

I used to not be annoying before, but now I just repeat, steal theorys and claim them as my own, and constantly spam on this page.

I am a piece of shit and cannot be compared to Patrick Jane, as he is not a spammer like me. I try to make Whoisredjohn.com, Whoisstoopkid.com.

I think I am a cult leader, and I think i can be compared to Brett Styles, but in reality no one really gives a fuck about me.

Comment if you think I should run around naked screaming Wayne Rigsby is Red John.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Why Rigsby is not Red John; If you want a respectable Theory , you have to cover plot holes, as well as interpret clues. Answer ALL of these or Rigsby isn't Red John. You can't just glaze over these things and say "every theory has plot holes," because that just proves YOUR theory isn't waterproof.

......................................

When Jane talks to Red John's voice in the limo in the finale of season 4, Rigsby is in handcuffs. The voice cannot be pre-recorded as it gives real and relevant responses to Jane. Explain.

Season one finale: How is Rigsby luring Jane to the farm, where he is sipping tea, when he is actually riding with Cho?

If Rigsby is Red John, why is he killing farm workers at the age of 10. These farm workers were bound by the hands, shot and dragged into the farm, so Rigsby must be one strong 10 year old to overpower these men. The killer dropped a high school class ring, furthermore Rigsby graduated high school at the age of 10 or below.



.....................................



Last of all, how do any of Jane's plans reflect he wants to catch Rigsby?

I don't know if you'll ignore this, or weasel out of answering these, but if you can't, stop saying you're being victimized because you think Rigsby is Red John.Your theories just aren't waterproof, it's just a mash of clues you put together in a kitchen blender. Where's my theory, you may ask? Focus on this one right here and I'll make a theory right here! :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16712 • By PelterSkelter
Show this theory

I'm bored with no theories. So I'll make my own!
On Red Rigsby ; did RJ ever use hypnotism on people prior to becoming entangled with PJ? Rigsby seemed most interested in acquiring this skill. Rigsby managed to manipulate Cho, the master of morals, to lie for him during an internal investigation. Rigsby is no where to be seen when BP is killed. When seen in the reunion episode, he clearly has charisma he keeps on the lowdown. When he meets PJ he quite markedly avoids shaking PJ's hand. Rigsby is leaving the show. I tried watching the show from the perspective of Owain knowing he was RJ from the beginning, but no one else in the cast does. It kinda plays. He would be the perfect draw-dropper - other than Cho, of course.
I've said before (and had it misinterpreted and then trolled) but it is possible that Rigsby saw the predatory nature of the sherrif during the Van Pelt sting at the restaurant. That could have been when Rigsby recruited the sherrif.

On another note - when Haffner says to Lisbon in the hospital 'we'll have time soon' or something to that effect, I wondered if RJ has promised Lisbon to Haffner, like he did with the twin sister he 'gave' to the cop desciple.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

That moment when the Stoopkid drama on this site is more interesting than the last few episodes of The Mentalist. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Came across an interesting youtube video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdfer_FQjLA featuring Zeena LeVay  --  her dad was Anton LeVay, founder of the Church of Satan 1966 -- TRUE STORY -- and it got pretty big at that time -- kind of like what Scientology is now, with celebrities..anyway...

Heller MUST have borrowed from this for sure...

Anton LeVay was a:
CARNIVAL GUY in his teenage years 
started a CULT with freaky rituals involving naked women
is referred to in the video as "A SHOWMAN"
Also called a "RECLUSE" -- because he started to send others in his place as he got older

Sounds a lot like BRET STILES  -- I wonder if BRET STILES HAD A CARNIE UPBRINGING, too?  

Oh, that's right, he's dead...LOL



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In thr season 4 finale the one where jane fakes like he killed lisbon and rigsby there isna HUGE clue.
Well maybe its a small clue.
When that lady darci goes to the morgue to check up on the bodies
She discovers rigsbys is obviously fake.
There is a very distinct i think yellow toe tag on the sureagates toe.

***The exact type of toe tag was on the bike that red john provided for jane to ride to meet him.
Check it out for yourselves.
Its draped on the front of the bike.

Conclude whatever u want but this was one of many clues for me.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on